Reviewer Photos & Videos
Just opened a new tube today only to it half empty. Seriously this isn’t good enough. Yeah it’s a good product and it’s a decent price but having a family of 4 this annoys me.
Purchased in April 2021.
Got a cavity and my teeth are yellow now
This stuff is very strong but the freshness only lasts like one hour and then your teeth feel gross again, as soon as I started using this my teeth have gotten worse and they were perfectly fine before, they are more yellow and get plaque sooner and the mint is so strong right after rinsing it is PAINFUL. Would just stick with oral b or Colgate, not whatever this stuff is made of.
Taste of bicarb
Bring back the original formula. My mouth do not feel fresh after each clean, it just taste like bicarb. It is considered a fail for a toothpaste. It is definitely missing the refreshing elements which the original formula had.
Be wary if you accidentally inhale some
I got distracted while brushing and accidentally inhaled a small amount. Resulted in choking and shortness of breath. Upon being able to breath again my throat is bleeding and feels burnt. Dangerous! Should have a warning label and keep out of reach of children. I don't know what is in this product but it is a hazard.
Tried this toothpaste (made in South Africa mind you) from Coles Supermarket in South Australia and the packaging splits down the join seam on the toothpaste body bloody useless crap.
Felt really good initially... but...
This toothpaste was *initially* fantastic, my teeth felt thoroughly clean and still retained that clean feeling for some time after eating...
However after about 3 days of using this product, I started getting a reaction on my lips and eventually inside my mouth. The skin inside my lower lips felt raw and it looked like it was about to bleed (thinning skin maybe?)
I switched to a different brand for about two weeks, mainly because using this one really hurt my lips... Then I decided to switch back to this one.
First usage, not so bad, ...SECOND time after sleeping, and now the inside of my mouth is once again raw and ready to bleed. Sorry, but this is going into the bin. Maybe that is why this toothpaste has the recommendation to 'don't use more than three times a day'
Bring back the good toothpaste!
The new extreme clean fresh is a fail. We've gone back to cheap stuff in whatever brand. If it's going to taste bad it might as well be cheap.
Loved the old bubbly formula!
Please bring back the old formula - it was the absolute best!! This new one is so terrible!!! No foam, peeling skin on inside of cheeks, gross taste.
Made my mouth peel
I had used Macleans extreme clean whitening for over 8 years. Thought the new packaging looked a bit old school when I bought it. Didn't realise that they'd also failed by altering a tried and tested formula. For a few days in a row, the skin in my mouth started peeling and it clicked that the toothpaste was the only common item I had tasted. Don't know what they put in this stuff but I won't be using it again.
Won't be buying this anymore
Worst taste and feeling, the original felt like it cleaned my teeth and freshened my breath. The new one feels chalky and after brushing I feel like I need to brush a second time. It doesn't foam up like it used to and if I had to compare it to another toothpaste I would say it is similar to the brand Aim, cheap and nasty.
New flavour is the worst!
I'm so picky with toothpastes and have been happily using Macleans extreme clean for years now. The new formula tastes and feels gross. Really dropped the ball here. Makes me wonder what kind of test group was used, if any. I get the feeling Macleans has lost quite a few of it's long time customers. Hopefully they wake up and bring back the original.
The new Extreme Clean Fresh is not good - BRING BACK THE ORIGINAL FLAVOUR
I agree whole heartedley with the other reviewers on this page - Macleans have dropped the ball big time on this one. I rang to complain about the taste and asked why the flavour had changed. I also asked why there wasnt a warning on the pack but the rep from the call centre said that yes it had changed flavour and they were no longer making the original flavour. Unfortunately i cant even place what the actual taste of the original Extreme Clean Fresh was - Orange? Aniseed?
I would love to know if anyone out there has found a similar product to the original - let me know if you have
I Wholeheartedly Agree with Naomi
I absolutely loved the old 'bubbly' version.. After buying the 'new formula', I have been hunting high & low for the old one.. Even the supermarkets don't seem to stock much, if any, of the brand.. Macleans have just downgraded themselves to be on par with every other toothpaste on the market.. Very disappointing.. Will be looking for another brand.. This just doesn't cut it.. P.S The tube has 'Feedback' details, (referring a phone number & website) but when you go on their website, there is no email address or form to contact them in writing! Lame, to say the least.
Old formula: Great. New Formula: Gross.
I don't understand why they felt the need to completely change the flavour, colour, texture and foaming factor of this toothpaste all the while still marketing it under the same name with the same packaging. If they're that eager to make a new toothpaste, then make one; don't change a product that was great the way it was. I was so disappointed about the changes to this toothpaste as this has been my favourite toothpaste for years. Everything about it is now terrible.To sell another paste under the same packaging is misleading.
Worst and harmful toothpaste
I had bought it and used it and after 2 days, i immediately got three ulcers in my mouth due to the harsh chemicals used in the product , would never buy it again.
Questions & Answers
Sorry, there are no questions yet.
Get an answer from our members
ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.