Review your last buy on ProductReview.com.au
2Youi Car Insurance

Youi Car Insurance

 Verifiedyoui.com.au
2Youi Car Insurance
3.9

8,483 reviews

Positive vs Negative
76%24%
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • See allThumbnail
Claim Resolution Time
  • <10 minutes
  •  · 
  • <1 hour
  •  · 
  • <1 day
  •  · 
  • <1 week
  •  · 
  • 1-2 weeks
  •  · 
  • 3-4 weeks
  •  · 
  • 1-2 months
  •  · 
  • 3+ months
  •  · 
  • Never
Claim ApprovedYes · No
Customer Service
3.8
Timeliness
3.7
Job Satisfaction ?
3.6
Transparency ?
3.6
Value for Money
3.6

 AI reviews summary 

Pros
Customer service staff: Consultants are frequently described as friendly, professional, knowledgeable, and empathetic during phone interactions.
Pricing and savings: Significant premium reductions compared to other major insurers are common, with some instances of costs being halved.
Claims efficiency: The initial lodgement process for claims is often fast, with some users receiving approval and repair bookings within minutes.
Policy customisation: Staff work to tailor coverage to individual needs, often including extras like roadside assistance and windscreen cover at competitive rates.
Cons
Quoting process: The inability to obtain a quote entirely online is a recurring frustration, as the website requires a phone call to finalise pricing.
Sales pressure: Telephone interactions are sometimes perceived as pushy, with long questionnaires and repeated questions already answered online.
Claim delays: Extended timelines for assessments and repairs occur, occasionally involving poor communication from assessors or nominated repairers.
Repairer restrictions: Limited choice of repairers can result in long travel distances or disagreements regarding the quality and necessity of specific repairs.
Verdict

Youi is highly regarded for its personable Australian-based service and its ability to provide substantial savings on premiums. However, the requirement for lengthy phone consultations to obtain quotes and occasional friction during the repair and claims phase are notable drawbacks. While the initial sign-up and lodgement are efficient, long-term satisfaction often depends on the performance of their nominated third-party repairers.

5  Keith G.  · Not a Bot in the whole process Human Touch only
5  Carol  · I’m very happy with the level of service from first contact to setting up repairs to my new car.
5  Trent  · Highly recommend talking to Keele, she went above and beyond to help me out and won’t hesitate going with youi in the future. Thanks heaps Keele
5  Lorraine  · Fantastic service! I had my car assessed and approved within three days! Thank you Youi!
5  Stephen P.  · Always the better deal, pricing reasonable, agents always a pleasure to work with.
1  Maudez  · Terrible Customer services, logged a claim two weeks ago, still haven't heard back. Its like they intentionally delay and stall any claim they can.
Nick
Nick 16 posts
   Comprehensive

Insuring for the first year with Youi is generally competitive - however, in subsequent years the premium is jacked up. Best to shop around after the first 12 months. Also, they have a classic dark pattern in their app & UI, which allows you to make many changes to your policy, however you cannot actually cancel it without logging in via the… Read more

website (not the app) and 'requesting' cancelation. After which someone will try to call you/attempt to retain etc...

Andrew C.
Andrew C. VIC 3 posts
   Comprehensive

Some people like the whole "personal touch" of a salesperson calling back and asking the same old questions that to already answered in the online quote form. I'm not that person. I found the whole experience unnecessary, intrusive and a bit overwhelming. With other companies, it took me 5 mins to get a quote. With Youi it 5 mins online and then a… Read more

20min callback only to be given a quote that was almost twice as much for the cheapest that I had already got for comparable cover. Then there's the whole "hard sell" by trying to convince you to sign up there and then whilst I was still in the process of shopping around. To be clear, the sales lady (Mandy) was lovely and very thorough but just the whole lengthy process put me off.

Fab N.
Fab N. NSW
   Comprehensive

I have to say I’m very impressed with the service received from the Claims dept. From answering phone in the middle of the night, to organising a hire car, to assessment and receiving payout all within a few days of the car accident, it was all smooth and prompt and really good communication. Would recommend YOUI for car insurance. Show details

Ask the reviewer

Reviews with attachments

  • Thumbnail
Chris H.
Chris H. QLD
   Comprehensive

I had a good experience getting a new windscreen. Well informed text and the windscreen shop was great. Show details

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +3Thumbnail
Loretta73
Loretta73 3 posts
   Verified  Comprehensive

OMG they have been amazing. I was in a minor accident (other drivers ploughed through a give way sign). YOUI organised my repairs. They have kept me updated on everything, I was unaware but with my compulsory insurance I’m entitled to a hire care & free roadside assistance. Show details

  • Thumbnail
Adeleke
Adeleke 3 posts
   Verified  Comprehensive

Great people from start to finish. Had an incident and i was supported all through. The claim was settled within 2-3weeks Show details

  • Thumbnail
Kenneth S.
Kenneth S. Victoria
   Verified  Comprehensive

From the very first phone call, I was put in touch with incredibly helpful people who guided me through the whole process with exceptional courtesy and efficiency. I would definitely recommend YOUI to anyone, not just family. Thanks for your exceptional service. Regards, Ken Smith Show details

  • Thumbnail
Teresa Rafter
Teresa Rafter TAS 5 posts
   Comprehensive

Liz was great with getting an assessment for my car and letting me no that I would not have to pay excess , For the insurance company thanks to young guy for being so nice and Liz from youi keep up the good work.only been with youi for 2months Show details

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +2Thumbnail
Alex
Alex 9 posts
   Verified  Comprehensive

I had a very good experience. Customer service team were professional and prompt. The entire repair time to have my car back in my hands in new condition was less than 2 weeks. I am very pleased with the process and outcome. Thank you. Show details

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +2Thumbnail
Kristen J.
Kristen J. 7 posts
   Verified  Third Party Property Only

A claim was made by one of your customers who had hit my car while I was not there and my hushand was driving. She had not looked going through a round about, resulting in our Toyota Kluger Grande being deemed a write off. When you client would not make a claim you were kind enough to contact her and ask her to do so, which she did. We we provided… Read more

with a hire car so our son could continue getting his hours up to get his licence as he is starting university an hour a way soon. We had that car for 4 weeks. The payout settlement was nothing spectacular but much more than we expected. The customer service provided by Maree was outstanding! She was so happy and cheerful on the phone, extremely helpful and explained everything every step of the way, making a stressful situation far less stressful. Thankyou Maree and the claims team for such a positive experience

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
Hearsz
Hearsz QLD 11 posts
   Comprehensive

I can't thank YOUI enough for how incredibly easy they were able to organise my claim after my car was rear-ended in early February (2026). I also had forgotten to book a rental car in advance on the day I dropped off my car for repair. I was worried I may not be able to get a rental car at short notice, but with the help from Tim at YOUI,… Read more

after communicating with Hertz, I had a car within half an hour.

I can't thank YOUI enough for such great efficiency. One of the best decisions I've made in recent years was choosing them as my car insurer.

  • Thumbnail
Russel M.
Russel M. 3 posts
   Car Insurance

I was involved in an unfortunate accident with a Kangaroo on the morning of the 11 March '26 at 1:20am. Fortunately, I believe he/she managed to survive it, but can't be said for my car. I lodged a claim with Youi on their app at around 11:00am. No more than one minute passed before I received a call from a customer service agent, who then swiftly… Read more

arranged for my car to be assessed the following morning. This morning I took it in for assessment at 9:00am. I have just received notification of the claim being accepted and the car can be booked in for repair. That is terrific service, greatly appreciated and no red tape to deal with.

Find out how Youi Car Insurance compares to other Car Insurance

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
  • Thumbnail
rjrulz
rjrulz 2 posts
   Verified  Third Party Fire & Theft

Had a fantastic experience with Sierra today! She was very polite, patient and accomodating to finding the best deal on my car insurance. Previously I have been with AAMI which has historically given me a great rate for my car. Sierra went out of her way to assess how to bring my premium down, was patient with me checking in with AAMI, and… Read more

provided a call back later at my time. Sierra was able to provide a better product that AAMI (third party fire and theft with $5k cover for my car (which is enough) at approximately $60 cheaper than AAMI! $60 cheaper sure beats the loyalty tax I was paying with AAMI for the last 4 years. I hope Sierra is provided some commission for her outstanding customer service skills, including being empathetic to my current financial circumstances.

  • Thumbnail
Kelly Muldoon
Kelly Muldoon NSW 3 posts
   Comprehensive

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I rang Youi today to add an L-plater to my comprehensive car insurance and honestly expected the premium to skyrocket. I was pleasantly surprised to find that not only did it cost very little to add the extra driver, but after the consultant reviewed my details my insurance actually decreased by $80. The service was excellent, the assistant… Read more

was helpful and thorough, and the price was brilliant. A really positive experience and great value for money.

  • Thumbnail
Freon
Freon NSW 2 posts
   Comprehensive

There was a minor accident while parking and Youi insurance took care of the claim very well. I would like to specially call out HAWKESBURY ACCIDENT REPAIR CENTRE who did an amazing job and the car looked like new. Though there was a slight delay due to the delivery of an additional part but when I looked at the professionalism and the way they… Read more

handed over the car, I am ok to excuse the delay. This was my first claim ever and they did a great job, thank you!

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +4Thumbnail
cynthiawall
cynthiawall QLD 10 posts
 Published  · Edited   Verified  Comprehensive

Do not risk yours or your loved one’s lives using this insurer PLEASE! My life and every other road users life was risked for over 4 months while i was forced to drive the falling apart car, for over 8000km mostly on motorways in Brisbane and Gold Coast all the way down to Ballina and inland. Full Details to come… Show details

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
Frank
Frank 53 posts
   Verified  Comprehensive

I cancelled a policy on car insurance last year at the time the Youi website was barely working, it actually took weeks to be able to login in the first place I have screenshots demonstrating that as well. Youi charged me for this policy for an entire year, despite the car being taken and registered in another state and the policy being… Read more

unenforceable as it was registered under another registration and owned by another person. I reported this a month ago, actually longer but chased it up a month ago I was told if I spent time getting evidence of that registration transfer they'd refund me. I spent 4 hours getting messed around by VicRoads to finally get the information and I've now been ghosted they're ignoring me the last message was they're going to ask the manager if you'll do what he said he would when he deceived me that if I got this information I would be refunded.

The IT department claimed everything was working perfect and there's no way I could have tried to cancellation but I've since found screenshots showing how objectively broken the website was which I will attach to this review.

I don't want to have to go through afca after being deliberately misled I would be refunded for a product I never received that I cancelled that they're broken website didn't properly cancel but it looks like I might have to this is a disgrace I've been a customer for years they've made a fortune off me trying to money grub and keep revenue from an unenforceable policy I CANCELLED that by their own terms and conditions I never could have actually used because it was for a different car is disgusting I'm really offended at the complete lack of morality and being lied to.

Frank
Frank   

Lol they just rung 20m after posting this but hung up when I answered... Notes on file "Attempted to call customer"?

  • Thumbnail
Marshall
Marshall VIC 111 posts
   Verified  Comprehensive

Three caveats. ONE: this is the second time I’ve tried to get a quote from Youi. It was some years back so maybe they’d changed? TWO: this review is based more on what didn’t happen, than what did. So it is based on a lot of extrapolation from what (IMO) “ought” to have happened, but didn’t. THREE: (as below) I don’t have the breadth of… Read more

information that would be needed to make a partial “star” rating. Hence I’m left with a binary choice of true/false, good/bad, yes/no (or in this case 5/1). Hence the one star.

===============

My car insurance is coming due and my insurance company wants to apply a “loyalty tax” by increasing the premium by around 10%. So I (re)started looking around, with Youi high on my list as I’m retired and near shops and hence don’t do much mileage.

The Youi site asked all the normal insurance questions, so they had the same amount of data that all insurance companies use to determine a premium. However, unlike all of the other companies that I’d checked, they didn’t throw up a screen with my quote, they didn’t email me a quote. Instead, they phoned me, which left a message on my computer screen when I didn’t answer. I’m effectively deaf (which is why I didn’t answer), so I responded by text asking them to either message or email.

Black hole. Nothing.

So .. Youi had the same (and extra) data that other companies used to issue a quote, but insisted by their actions that they require a salesperson talk to the potential customer.

Extrapolation - pure conjecture on my part so take it with a (large) grain of salt. The only reason I could come up with is that their business model is based on the sale being closed by the salesperson, not by the actual cost of the product (despite their current advertising campaign claiming it to be low cost). That implies that their sales team is staffed with (tongue in cheek here) “used car salesmen” (working mainly on commission?).

I don’t want to be worked over by a salesperson, and I consider the business model of requiring that I do so to be unethical, hence the low star rating.

Latest follow-ups

Greg
Greg NSW
   Comprehensive

I have 4 car policies with Youi including 2 CTP. Purchased an additional car and shopped around online for insurance quotes. Got to Youi, spent my time answering their questions expecting a quote at the end like all others, but got to the final… Read more

piece and they requested my mobile number for a second time so I could be sent a PIN or SMS to access my quote. Of course no PIN (deceptive conduct?) but a sales agent called and I spent another 30 mins answering the standard questions I had just completed. Plus they had my other policies - not as though it was my first stab at car insurance! Policy quote was fine but the process to get there was beyond painful. I had to interrupt the sales agent at one stage and say ‘I just want my quote!’ Youi’s website and app are great but they won’t let the customer continue the online experience - everything ends with a phone call. I’d hate to think how difficult the claim process must be if this is how new customers are treated. Get with the 21st Century Youi!

 Follow-up  · Youi now gives the option to complete insurance either fully on line or request a call back. Much improved! They still asked me to call when cancelling a policy online. I ignored and a notice of cancellation was sent anyway.

Jon
Jon NSW 22 posts
 Published  · Edited   Comprehensive

Update as of 20.09.2026 For those with short attention spans, here is a summary: … Read more

YOUi customer service 5/5; Time taken to repair 4.5/5; and Quality of repair: 5/5. A couple of days after the accident I received a text indicating the damage will be assessed in 8 days and if repairs are approved then I'll be advised of where that will take place. I have never dealt with an insurer this way and have no idea of the process. Yes it was nice to be texting with the insurance company, but I couldn't get my head around the fact that my car would sit in a lot for over a week before being assessed, let alone repaired. In the scheme of things the damage was mild to moderate. I replied to the text asking why the 8 day delay? Are the assessors that busy? Later that day I got 2 texts. The first indicated that the assessor booked for the following week had been cancelled by YOUi. The second informed me that another assessment was now booked for the next day. The car was to then taken to the repair shop and 9 days later I picked up the car (Toyota Yaris). The repair was excellent. In case you didn't get the memo: EXCELLENT. While chatting with the repairer, he made clear that repairs to established brands like Toyota, Mazda and Kia are straight forward, with car parts both readily available and are cheap. But if the car damaged is a new brand or worse, both a new brand and electric, parts are relatively expensive and not widely available. Great to know as I was so close to buying a Chinese made electric car. The damage to my car was the bumper and one door panel. A better job could not be done! First class job it was. From accident to collecting my car took 11 days. I am very happy with the workmanship and with YOUi staff interacting with me. To be safe, if you join YOUi and make claim, don't just accept texts. Read them closely, if something is unclear, clarify the matter with YOUi. When I did this, ie spotting an error in the assessment date, the process was moved forward and I got my car back a week sooner than was planned. Of course I do not blame the YOUi reps I spoke to, Calina and Edgar, for the wrong assessment date first given to me, as many steps in the repair process are automated. =============================== ============= Update as at 06.09.2026: Yesterday I posted about YOUi's renewal process, mentioning that I only signed up with YOUi last year and to date have not had an accident, so I cannot comment on the claim process.

What a difference a day makes.

Today I had an accident. No injuries, low to moderate damage to the Toyota. Online I saw that to claim I need to complete a form with multiple details eg policy # etc. Like most folk, I do not know my policy # by heart. So I called YOUi and gave my car registration. Edgar who picked up the phone was very polite and helpful. He said to call from home to complete the claim process. He arranged for a tow truck to collect the car and offered a reimbursement of up to $100 for a taxi or UBER from where the car is dropped off by the tow truck driver. Being a Sunday the car is taken to a holding yard pending it being taken to an assessor at a later date. The tow truck driver Paul was a pleasure to deal with: polite and kept me updated on his arrival time.

When I got home I called YOUi and spoke to Calina. Like Edgar and Paul, she was a pleasure to deal with. We went through standard questions and she explained the claims/repair process before confirming how I would like to be updated over time eg SMS? Email? Phone calls?

So far, so very good. Now my hope is that the assessment takes place soon; that the repair is completed as quickly as possible and I get the car back in two shakes of a lamb's tail. ==================

Update as at 05.09.2026: A year is almost up since I first signed up with YOUi. I can't say how good or bad they are in regards to claims, because I made no claims during the year, as I had no accidents. Recently I received the renewal notice: premium for 2026-27 is up 11% and so is the standard excess. But the excess for glass damage is 4x what it was. Before deciding on whether to stay with YOUi, I will need to check out the competition. What I did not like is that amongst the renewal paperwork there was mention that the policy will be renewed on expiry and I will be debited automatically. If I do not want that to take place, I must call YOUi. I get that YOUi may think it's good practice to offer a renewal and an automatic debit of the customer's credit card without the customer having to interact with YOUi. That may be reasonable to a degree, but what is I think is not reasonable is that customers are forced to call in order to disallow YOUi from debiting them. Perhaps YOUi could allow customers to email if they do not want to renew or if they want to change the coverage? With my previous insurer, GIO, after receiving the renewal paperwork, if I did not want to renew I could either call and haggle for a better price or just let the policy lapse, not call and go elsewhere. This is a much better process from a customer's viewpoint). ============================== Original post in 09.2025:

For a decade my car was insured with GIO. Annually I needed to negotiate a better premium than they initially sent me. This time they declined to negotiate. So I told them I will shop around. Budget Direct offered a similar premium as GIO for the same risks and agreed value. Youi offered $220 lower premium for the same risks and identical agreed value. The fellow I spoke to at Youi, Moscow, was very personable, professional and transparent about Youi's policies. I am very happy with the experience.

 Follow-up  · This is a follow up (in 2 parts) to my review in 09.2026 ====== FOLLOW UP AS AT 20.09.2026 For those with short attention spans, here is a summary: YOUi customer service 5/5; Time taken to repair 4.5/5; and Quality of repair: 5/5. A couple of days after the accident I received a text indicating the damage will be assessed in 8 days and if repairs… Read more

lanacap66
lanacap66 VIC
   Comprehensive

Cannot fault the service, outstanding. My quote was $648 less than previous insurer plus I get road side assist, doesn't get better than that. It definately made my day. Well done Youi. Show details

 Follow-up  · Fortunately, I haven't needed roadside assistance, BUT, however I'm over the Moon with my Comprehensive cover with Youi... I had a HUGE Saving swaping tou Youi

Find out how Youi Car Insurance compares to other Car Insurance

Know better, choose better.

Compare all

Positive reviews

Tina
Tina SA
   Comprehensive

Left RAA after being with them for over a decade and and switched with Youi. They were $30 cheaper than RAA and you get roadside assist included with Youi. I made my first claim recently with youi, it was smooth sailing with exceptional customer service. The crash repair they sent me to in Stepney are excellent. Dynamic Paint and Panel. Show details

Cyrus
Cyrus ACT
   Comprehensive

I had two incidents with my car earlier this year, and the Youi team was supportive and professional on both occasions. I really appreciated their help through what could have been a stressful time. Based on my experience, I’d happily recommend Youi for car insurance. Show details

Robert P.
Robert P. VIC 5 posts
   Comprehensive

The level of courtesy and general "interaction" (mainly with Jason and Gerald) has been excellent. My car is yet to be repaired, but I am confident the Kerrigans, Youi's selected repairer will do a great job. What has really been annoying is the time I have had to wait before someone answeres the phone. COMMENT: It seems a bit counterproductive… Read more

to continue run your extensive TV promotion for new business whn you dont have enough receptionists to promptly answer calls.

Negative reviews

RJL
RJL VIC
   Comprehensive

Too expensive & customer service too long-winded & time wasting. Doing comparisons prior to renewing my annual comprehensive insurance phoned and it took too long to give me a quote that was $600 more than the quote i had received from AAMI maybe spending too much on advertising rather than providing value for money for customers Show details

Vince R.
Vince R. 24 posts
   Comprehensive

Youi advertise very heavy on price discount I have a quote from them for $2200 dollars Bingle is currently $1370 so where's the discount Perfect driving record and never any issues What rubbish advertising Show details

Boris S.
Boris S. QLD
   Comprehensive

Long story shorter, first time ever I needed roadside assistance in my life. 2hs and 4 additional calls from the time when my car was assessed to when tow service was confirmed. Had no issues with technician and tow service but very unhappy with the way this was managed by oncall staff so this 1 star is for that. Very unhelpful and not… Read more

understanding, coming across almost rude. Had to tow car to the closest relatives 6kms away from location while I additionally requested taxi to be reimbursed as per policy. The reason-my home was 23kms from location and my current mechanic within 20kms was not working yesterday. Did not want to tow me to the closest petrol station to my house within the range neither. Apparently, according to the rules and regardless of being worded out differently in policy, you can only be towed to your house and mechanic within 20kms. It's pretty amazing what happened. Don't have any issue with the policy and the insurance but yesterday's situation has amazed me to that point to leave this poor score because of that.

Recent reviews

Therese
Therese QLD
   Comprehensive

This is the 2nd year I have been with Youi. Customer Service was above my expectations - Assistance with reviewing insurance excellent - Pricing excellent - Policy details better then my previous insurer of over 20 years.. Show details

Baz
Baz QLD 3 posts
   Comprehensive

A big thank you to Jason who gave the personal touch rather than the hard sale salesman. He explained very clearly what was available and on completion of my request I was very satisfied that I was receiving what I wanted. The whole process was very professional and not rushed . Bazz Show details

ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.