Review your last buy on ProductReview.com.au
Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA)

Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA)

 Verified
Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA)
1.6

298 reviews

Positive vs Negative
13%87%
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • See allThumbnail
Transparency ?
1.7
298 reviews
1  Carol  · AFCA a major case BOQ Bank ...elder abuse.dragging on 12 months AFCA ..bank backed will string it out! Beware
1  sonya w.  · Favour Banks all the TIME DONT WASTE YOUR TIME WITH THIS RUBBISH ORGANISATION
1  Suzette lo  · Don't bother. Toothless tiger. Bows to whatever large financial institutions tells them to do.
1  crapstratamanager  · Corrupted and criminal organisation, much more useless than I thought they are
1  Grant  · Afca, like most or all.dept a waste of time. Do not do anything to help consumers with dodgy companies
5  Terry  · AFCA has helped me to resolve multiple issues with various banks and a BNPL provider.
Bernie
Bernie SA 7 posts
 

AFCA conducted their interaction to the highest of customer service standards. The thing to be aware of is AFCA is constrained by specific limits as to what they investigate. The systemic problem with the process is who and how their investigation can involve. They fulfilled their limited capacity to resolve disputes in a most compassionate, empathetic, and professional manner.

Ask the reviewer
Doug
Doug QLD 17 posts
 

AFCA is hopelessly biased as it must be given that its totally funded by AFS licencees and there is no real oversight. IMO this was deliberately designed into AFCA since the finance industry is vastly more significant than any government and it is imperative that big players enjoy total protection but the so called watchdog is kept at arms length from government so that the grossly overpaid fatcats infesting Canberra can deny accountability. Case managers bend over backward to let financial companies off the hook, the 'service complaints' facility is way beyond farcical, and the Independent Assessor is more of the same. I have yet to deal with the AFCA ombudsman however given the shambolic case management, service complaints facility and Independent Assessor, I don't expect the ombudsman will be any more effective. I have certainly found particular financial companies are highly protected to the point where AFCA refuses to even accept a complain against them. Three examples are Australian Stock Reports, Perpetual Corporate Trustee and Melbourne Securities Corporation. Another company Assetora Australia Ltd is given unlimited time to dream up fanciful excuses despite reams of damning evidence of deliberate malpractice. AFCA's own rules define 'systemic complaints' but again this department is utterly useless and as with all other AFCA departments, it appears to spend more time inventing inane reasons why it won't fulfil its charter than it does actually dealing with blatantly obvious issues.

… 
Overit
Overit QLD 42 posts
 

A review forced on me by Hollard- cancelling, forcing out Breach of contract to AFCa, collusion, fraud, convolute, the amoutn of illegal acts - both companies carry out- notwithstanding taking money for cover that is immediately Breached- to defraud, and AFCA issue a half page- 3 line of boxes- without any of my bulk folders proof of fraud, backdating altering to which - No make safe- fraud- on major storms of 2020 to 2022- including works to be done- via Hollard- Turned to Hollard covered and paid. For Hail- at claim 1 - which no evidence supported. Then more obvious was the Q AFCA then asked me, why i did not fix the house- just answer the Q. Wellwhy cause you did not cover hail- even respond at claim 1- you deleted reports, withheld, dod nto make safe- allowed the house and policy to be destroyed all monies- everything i own- and issue a half page responst- that also turned into- accusing me of behaviour to refuse to deal- respond- AFCA- Hollard eluding they had a decision in their favour- (yes this is in their favour) but AFCA refuse to admit this is a decision- but then HOllard boasted further AFCA agree- but i have no decision i am in Limbo telling me to get a lawyer- and leaving my house destroyed further- that i had to spend monies to get the roof- done that many roof reports- avoided showing any hail, roof damage- just make up - anyone that wrote a proper report- were withheld- including putting me into accomadation- to get me out of the house- to do a silicone patchup job- Hollard put decisions on file- 5 claims were covered- hid that- hid it all- fake file- 2 copies of reports- original and altered colluded with suppliers- full cover inlcuding roof was on file- refuse the files- the illegal acts including going to my bank to cancell my deductions- and i get a half page - from AFCA- notwithstanding - the initial months- was all discussion with HOllard- yet its my complaint- meant to be independent- THIS IS WHAT I GOT- that AFCA- then blocked Email boxes- refused me access to the portal- which was also blocked from the start- deliberate or not- did not fix it- i could not see any of HOllards- uploads- that then had to be issued via usb- and in memo form- pdf format-all dated the same- no reports, 1 report - and a deleted claim- used that they say never happened- criminal acts that we all know to backdate a claim to orirignla date- to elude yuou paid all- and i fixed nothing- to alter the claim nos and dates- and still fail to make safe ever- in 7 years and dumpe me- systemic go to afca to get answers they cant give- YEP A JOKE- yet who is protecting these companies- Then ask me why i did not fix- not why they did not Make safe- ref. To Asic sues Hollard- case in homeowners favour- no makesafe destroyed the house- they let her sit in major damage- just like mine but mine was multiple storms- and dont dare confront them they just alter the files- and continue- AFCA accused me of no proof of HOllard- systemic issues that they themselves had reported- online- is proof. AFCA HOLLARD collusion to defraud- is horrific- criminality Please note- my reviews are also HIDDEN-

… 

Reviews with attachments

  • Thumbnail
Fair Go
Fair Go 40 posts
 Published  · Edited

Bogus – I suspected they wear bogus, But I am still shocked, They don't care about issues of Customer suicide any more than the bank did. 2 months in, I just had to ask the case worker to define what complaint he was making to the bank and he had no idea Lead AFCA Ombudsman Banking and Finance told me that AFCA is not the Police, they can't make banks talk to customers about their complaints. So!

  • Thumbnail
Matey8
Matey8 WA 7 posts
 

This must be a joke, who came up with the idea of replacing the independent banking and insurance ombudsman with AFCA ? Not only are they funded by banks and insurance companies but also staffed with people who worked for them and were parachuted into the cushy mostly working from home and set your own hours jobs at AFCA. Takes at least 8 weeks before a case manager is even appointed to a complaint then many more months to investigate and come to a decision, and that is for a simple case where no legal questions arise. Surprised to see a reviewer gave them 5 stars and had the case resolved by AFCA in 5 days when the financial company is given 4 weeks to reply before a complaint even goes in line to be appointed a case manager. For as long as the banks and insurance are allowed to regulate themselves the banks and insurance companies will continue to make billions in profits from the customers forced to put up with lack of service and be denied justice. The only way things can change is with a Senate inquiry.

… 
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +4Thumbnail
Veezy
Veezy 64 posts
 

Based on my experience AFCA works for the companies that fund them - the banks, insurers and super funds. It is not unbiased. The quality of staff and the service they provide is another serious issue. Bank complaints - I have just been through the process. 3months of waiting, 2 Afca case workers and end result - they failed to understand the complaint, failed to acknowledge the bank did breach guidelines and law, failed to hold bank accountable for abuse, negligence and mishandling and destroying evidence. What is the point of AFCA if they can’t manage glaring evidence and victims highlighting the breaches for AFCA.

AFCA is not government run. AFCA has limited powers. AFCA is not efficient. AFCA is not fair and unbiased. ****There is a very important petition to have AFCA investigated. Please sign the petition (and share with family & friends) as it is closing soon - on 23 April 2025. Name of petition, which will come up if you search in browser:

Petition EN7196 - Legislation Reform pursuant to Federal Court Declaration and AFCA Inquiry

Increasingly Australians are being ripped off by banks and insurers. We are pushed to go to AFCA to complain externally as the banks refuse to do the right thing when you complain internally. We are misled that we will be given a fair and efficient review at AFCA. This is not happening. See photos for online groups that have had to form to try get accountability because the finance industry and Afca have rigged the system. Also please support independent senators and candidates that **will** fight for victims of bank and insurer corruption and misconduct. See attachments for helpful sources. Please look into each as knowledge is power. The banks and insurers are abusing us. The government has failed us. Independents are our only hope.

… 
  • Thumbnail
TennisWarlord
TennisWarlord QLD 7 posts
 

Limited by shares company - Can be bought and influenced and probably has – They are a limited company. This means they can be influenced and directed to take certain actions with enough shares bought. It also means collusion across the industry with zero independence. When you have the word limited at the end of your legal business structure name, you can have shares sold on the ASX and privately. It's too obvious they are not independent. They just record the evidence you have over the financial companies and then change it to dilute it down to weaken your case. They haven't done much with mine and keep trying to re-word what I've said so it makes who I've got issues with seem innocent. They keep coming back with snarky responses asking why I wasn't aware of the terms etc. While I'm saying they've been changed on me with zero response back. They're very selective on what they want to respond too. So if you put more than one section in on what's going on, they'll only respond to selective sections which you can clearly see the wording is favouring that credit card company right off the bat.

… 
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +1Thumbnail
Abused by CBA
Abused by CBA NSW
 

AFCAsenateinquiryNOW - important – For anyone with issues as a result of using AFCA to try hold your bank or insurers accountable for wrong doing, please know there are FB groups of people in the same boat. AFCA is not fit for purpose and is not independent. They are not fair and can not protect you from harm, or further loss. Their outcomes are weak and bias in my experience and always fail to be fair given the evidence. Much evidence shows that AFCA fail to hold banks and insurers to account and fail to be unbiased. There is little Transparency.

Please join the fb groups as we need to work as a group to show the government that the system needs urgent change to provide an independent organization that is not corrupted and not connected to the finance industry who are causing the harm to our lives, health and finances.

The media have reported often yet nothing is changing. We need people power and have an MP on board right now. Please join us and share this with anyone else affected by AFCA who failed to do their job properly when handling your complaint.

… 

Latest follow-ups

Ali A.
Ali A.
 

AFCA appears to be ineffective. I am surprised that the Australian government permits this organisation to operate within the country. It seems to primarily protect financial institutions at the expense of citizens. I encourage Australian citizens to reach out to the Prime Minister, government officials, and parliament members to advocate for the organisation's shutdown. The government should scrutinise AFCA for potential corruption and links to organised crime, including any secret collaborations with financial institutions against the public. The numerous negative comments about AFCA suggest an urgent need for investigation and a halt to its questionable activities. Citizens are urged to contact the Australian Parliament promptly.

… 

 Follow-up  · Unfortunately, this corrupt organisation is still operating!

Wise Owl
Wise Owl 3 posts
 

Frustrated by delays, obstructions, and other blockages, the world of finance complaints is a maze! https://afja.org.au

 Follow-up  · I can’t see any improvements, [Content Removed] thankfully maps the maze and provides inexpensive comprehensive kits for main categories of complaint. Superannuation failures and losses seem to be on the rise, which is concerning, losing a nest egg is a nasty experience needing careful attention.

Wise Owl
Wise Owl   

Help for the public at last! external link 

Nicholas W.
Nicholas W. 21 posts
 

UTTERLY USELESS – I got scammed out of my superannuation onlineI took the CBA to AFCA for negligence, of course they locked shoulders against me. If you have lost too much AFCA uses a very arbitrary ceiling figure and just days "sorry, nothing to see here". A totally empty vessel full of bloated bureaucrats and w#nkers. I also went to the federal police and used two recovery agencies. Scam on scam.

AFCA is full of itself, it is hopelessly inadequate. Over funded by the taxpayer, it already witnesed CBA prosecuted with ASIC for fraud.

The CBA used shareholders funds for it's defence. The shareholders sued their own bank! And AFCA looked away.

What kind of nonsense is this? AFCA cannot find it's rear end with two hands. That is the truth.

Just like the governor general getting an extra $200 k for nothing, taxpayer money, AFCA sits on its butt watching the world go around.

It cares not what happens. It is clearly in bed with the big four crooked banks in Australia who are equally as incompetent, careless and brutally greedy.

Avoid AFCA. It's a hollow shell, a joke.

… 

 Follow-up  · Hard not to think these people are in bed with scammers. In any event the crooks at coins markets.io are on for a nasty surprise. Vigilante justice.

Positive reviews

lorraine h.
lorraine h. NSW
 

Exceptional Service – AFCA Achieved What My Bank Failed to Do. I cannot praise the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) highly enough. Their intervention was invaluable in helping me recover funds lost through unauthorised transactions, after a deeply disappointing experience with Greater Bank. Despite Greater Bank's own systems flagging the suspicious activity early, I found their response to be wholly inadequate. I contacted the bank on four separate occasions regarding the unauthorised transactions, yet there appeared to be no meaningful effort to recover my funds.

To make matters worse, after requesting a replacement bank card, I discovered ten days later that it had never been sent. The bank acknowledged this oversight when I contacted them again.

Frustrated by the repeated failures and lack of effective action, I finally turned to AFCA.

The difference was extraordinary.

AFCA acted with remarkable speed, professionalism and efficiency, achieving an outcome that I genuinely believe would never have been possible without their intervention.

What had been an incredibly frustrating experience was finally resolved thanks to an organisation that took my concerns seriously and ensured they were properly addressed.

I am enormously grateful to AFCA for their assistance. It is reassuring to know that an independent organisation exists to hold financial institutions accountable when consumers are let down.

My heartfelt thanks to AFCA. Your work makes a genuine difference, and in my case, it made all the difference.

… 

Find out how Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) compares to other Financial Services

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
Clayton
Clayton NSW
 

FAST! We had an issue with a service provider and within 24 hrs AFCA had contacted the provider - 5 stars for that! The provider contacted us almost immediatley (forgot to copy all the people so created an issue). We responded and the issue is not resolved. Soooo impressive to see the speed of action of AFCA. Congratulations to all the team.

 Follow-up  · The key was that AFCA passed our complaint to the body we were having trouble with. This resulted in a very quick escalation in the company, resulting in them working with us to resolve.

Jane D.
Jane D.
 

Absolutely fantastic and compassionate service. Present facts that abide by the rule book and the outcome will always be favourable.

Negative reviews

Marcus M.
Marcus M. 5 posts
 Published  · Edited

SLIGHTLY MORE CORRUPT THAN A PRISON GANG. You are better to pull your own teeth from your head and eat them, than you are to lodge an AFCA complaint looking for a just or reasonable result.

 Follow-up  · I took two complaints to the AFCA. 1. My stockbroker sold my shares without my consent, 2. Then they locked me out of my account for ten days with no way to access it. I lost $15K as a direct result of CMC Markets actions. The AFCA found the stockbroking firm were not liable in any way. Just like 75% of all AFCA claims, the AFCA found my claims… 

GypsyCat
GypsyCat Victoria 16 posts
 

Customer service staff are rude, unhelpful, with no manners. Case workers in the first and second stage are blatantly biased in favour of the firm, uninformed, unfair, dismissing and invalidating in your face the black on white evidence you provided against the firm, ticking off the boxes to churn their cases focused on quantity not quality of assessment. Their bias, ignorance and procedural unfairness are beyond words. Service complaint is the final option, but all it will do is a slap on the wrist, with occasional compensation in severe cases. We need a Senate Enquiry into AFCA's design, terms of refence, scope and operations which are deeply flawed from the start - convenient for the government, useless for the consumers, often inflicting more pain and psychological distress for people already abused by the financial firms.

… 
Sunshine Band
Sunshine Band NSW
 

This organisation is strongly focused on assisting the banks. The banks have experts and know the expectations, we as lay people don’t. For example, I provided what I believed was evidence. They ruled for the bank claiming I did not provide evidence. They did not specify why my evidence was not accepted, or Ben warm me that it wasn’t in a format they would accept.

Recent reviews

Merry
Merry VIC 4 posts
 

They don't even investigate your complaint and rush you to accept the smallest amount of settlement possible especially if you are a person of colour. Never got any details of their "investigation", never got any support or options on what I could do next if I don't accept the settlement and they're run by the banks and insurance companies FOR the banks and insurance companies. The government needs to step up and investigate AFCA themselves with an independent body that isn't funded by fat cats that run the financial industry and have enough from all of us money to sweep our problems under the carpet.

… 
Carol P.
Carol P. VIC 2 posts
 

AFCA a brush off from banks .time wasters on major bank complaints .experts at verballing BOQ and AFCA now face closure by the ACCC . AFCA operate with criminal intent .BEWARE

Mary C
Mary C
 

The AFCA behaves like all Ombudsman globally - they back the organisation the complainants have grievances with - in my opinion from experience. I have submitted complaints with Ombudsmen in the UK and recently with the AFCA in Australia, regarding a complaint against the Commonwealth bank. The pat spiel they both spew out when delivering the news that the complainant has not been successful is identical, so could even be derived from A.I. It's patronising at best and infuriating at worst. My case with the AFCA was drawn out and included me obtaining my case file via the FOI Act (Freedom of Information), to obtain phone recordings. Throughout the case the AFCA admitted that the bank could have been clearer disclosing information, but they also said that banks rarely admit when they have made mistakes. I was offered a bribe by the bank to close the case, which was a rare gesture apparently, but I refused, as this token would not have covered potential fees I would have incurred. The case came to a natural end as my term with the bank reached its end date, after which the AFCA finally admitted that the bank had indeed failed to disclose fees. This should have happened earlier - no excuses. They subsequently requested an apology from the bank. This was an insult so I refused the apology and demanded that the case stay open, as I did not want to add to their statistics of complaints closed, due to mutual settlement. However, the AFCA closed the case regardless. In my opinion it would be a complete waste of time for complainants to proceed with an AFCA case, in the hope they will settle the matter you have with a financial institution. It would be better to engage a solicitor, but if this option would be prohibitively expensive, perhaps seek council with Legal Aid; a Paralegal or a lawyer in training.

… 
Purple Milk
Purple Milk NSW
 

My experience with AFCA was honestly awful. The process dragged on for over a year and was completely draining. I spent months providing documents, evidence and detailed explanations, and by the end I was left wondering what the point of the whole process even was. The final outcome felt narrow, technical and completely disconnected from the real issue. It felt like the financial firm was given the benefit of every technical argument, while I was expected to prove things that an ordinary person would never realistically have access to.

That is the part that frustrated me the most. AFCA presents itself as a place consumers can go when they have a dispute with a financial firm, but my experience did not feel like consumer protection. It felt like a long administrative process where the complainant does all the work, waits forever, and then gets told why the financial firm’s technical position wins.

For a complex investment complaint, I found the process slow, exhausting and ultimately useless. It may look fair and formal from the outside, but that is not how it felt going through it.

Based on my experience, I would be very careful before relying on AFCA for anything serious involving a financial firm. I went in hoping for a fair review. I came out feeling like the process offered very little practical protection at all.

… 

Find out how Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) compares to other Financial Services

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
Ken Sunter
Ken Sunter
 

This entire process wit the AFCA has been an absolute waste of time. It took them 4 months to advise they could not proceed based on simple qualifying criteria that could have been advised for the outset. All they have served to do is further protect an Australian Based Finance Company, who has held $250,000 of our company funds for over 20 months without refunding it as promised on numerous occasions.

David S.
David S. 3 posts
 

They claim to be independent but have the bank's best interests in mind. my case i raised with the bank is now aproaching 18mths and i dont even get answers to question anymore, they just dodge them. Shocking people to deal with. the same old MPMW type (max pay, min work) that is so common these days. i wish there was a lower score than 1 star

Questioner
Questioner 6 posts
 

A "free and fair" dispute service? Don't believe it for a second If you are counting on AFCA to give you a genuinely independent hearing against an insurer, read this first. I brought a straightforward loss of rent claim. I submitted evidence, which included statutory evidence that over rides the insurer’s PDS. (Notice to quit, premises uninhabitable due to water ingress). I submitted documentation. I set out exactly how the policy applied. And AFCA still sided with Hutch (Strata Insurance) and declined the claim, without, ever really understanding a single thing I put in front of them. That is the part that makes my blood boil. It is one thing to lose. It is another thing entirely to lose and be handed "reasoning" that reads like it was reverse-engineered to justify the insurer's position. The facts were ignored. The documentation was ignored. The policy wording was treated as an afterthought. Whatever "independent assessment" is supposed to mean, this was certainly not it. AFCA markets itself as the fair, free alternative to the courts, the body that exists so that ordinary people can be heard to get justice. In my experience it is nothing of the sort. It is a process that claims to be impartial whilst delivering outcomes that conveniently support the insurer. Definitely, do not feed the hand that bites you. The "free" part is real. The "fair" part is marketing. And while we're talking about marketing, actually READ the five-star reviews on here. Read them slowly. Notice how many are vague, glowing, and free of the specific detail. We need to ask ourselves yourself who benefits from the generic praise sitting on top of every genuine complaint. I'll let you draw your own conclusions about how the five-star average came to exist. Once you've read enough of them, you may have yours too. To anyone walking into this process, be warned. Document everything, keep every email, every date. Assume nothing you submit will be given the weight it deserves, because in my case it wasn't. A well-resourced insurer walked away validated, and a legitimate claimant walked away with a result that does not reflect the evidence. AFCA had one job, to be the impartial umpire, and it sided with the insurer. Either engage a solicitor or go to XCAT after the determination has been declined and challenge your insurer there. You will have greater success. The system is a shambles as are the employees within AFCA.

… 
Ali
Ali NSW 23 posts
 

AFCA was one of the most frustrating and disheartening experiences I have ever been through. More than a year of delays, endless bureaucracy, generic responses, and absolutely no genuine concern for the human being behind the case. While my life was collapsing financially and emotionally, AFCA moved at a painfully slow pace with zero urgency. I lost my income, my apartment became uninhabitable, my savings disappeared, yet none of that seemed to matter. Everything felt designed to protect insurance companies and hide behind technical wording instead of delivering real fairness. AFCA claims to be an independent authority for consumers, but my experience was that ordinary people are left powerless while large corporations with lawyers and resources are protected at every step. The entire process felt cold, mechanical, and completely detached from reality. By the end, I honestly felt less like a person seeking help and more like a file being processed through a system that has no empathy and no accountability. An incredibly disappointing and exhausting experience.

… 
Gav
Gav VIC 3 posts
 

AFCA says it’s independent authority, but in reality they work for bank. I my case they even don’t talk about the core concern of my complaint and give it in banks favour.

Elizabeth B.
Elizabeth B. WA
 

When I asked for help to have banks change their rules so they can't just close customers' accounts in order to have us do what they command, I was told that is not the role of AFCA, that I can only act on my own behalf and that I should take the $500 offered to me for a nice dinner out instead. After closing this complaint because I am not interested in money, I want action, I have found out that AFCA is funded by the financial institutions they are meant to be impartial to. How is this fair for customers? Where do we go to be heard? I am disgusted by the unethical practice of companies, especially in the financial industry. What a parasitic, sad game to play with human lives. We need to do better than this.

… 
kabuki
kabuki
 

I went to AFCA wholeheartedly, hoping to get a fair assessment of my disagreement with my bank. It turned out that AFCA completely ignored my argument and sided with the bank. AFCA, in fact, is nowhere near what it claims to be. My experience demonstrated that AFCA is not an independent organisation, but a puppet of the bank. Fairness is not exhibited in the organisation.

Neil Benson
Neil Benson WA 3 posts
 

An organisation clearly bought and paid for by the financial institutions. My experience showed the organisation had no interest in the real issue and were there to cover for the banks.

ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.