Review your last buy on ProductReview.com.au
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
harmo
harmo117 posts
  Verified

Are you (or someone you know) an avid pizza or bread baking fan? This steel is great if you're looking for that crispy pizza crust or bake your own bread without the costs of specialist pizza ovens or other MUCH more expensive equipment. It's a plate of steel, what's special about it?

Believe it or not, this steel (even the thicker 3/8") is much cheaper than buying a cut plate from the local steel supplier. I did some "shopping around" and found that a comparable piece from three steel suppliers had quotes that ranged from $90-179 Australian EACH, and that's picking it up from the warehouse. So I bought two of these instead for the ticket price of $72 each delivered, but with a discount code, I actually got it down to $65 each. That is still much cheaper than some of the $170+ charged by domestic stores, and nearly $400 delivered price from overseas stores.

Shipping heavy plate is really expensive.... normally.

These steels are 3/8" or 9.5mm thick, (There's a thinner model is only 6mm or so that's about $7-10 cheaper) and definitely heavier than even the dome-lidded cast iron loaf pans like the Brunswick, and Skitchen's "Brisbane Large" that I've reviewed . At 11Kg per steel, I was a little worried about sticking two of them in a 60cm wide wall oven (I have a base model Neff) but that load is successfully held up by the shelving. The steels themselves are NOT wide enough to run on my rails so I could take the shelving out (much as I wanted to), and do sit at a slight lean because my shelf curves up either side. We're talking only a few degrees off from level leaning left/right depending on which side I raise to fit. It causes no problems with any steel-worthy bread dough, and hasn't caused any issues with pizza toppings yet.

This is a carbon steel, NOT stainless steel, so it will rust if you don't look after it. So like cast iron cookware, maintaining a seasoned coat requires ongoing effort, but will prevent rust and create a reasonably non-stick surface. Like all seasoned cookware, it's NOT dishwasher safe, (it's the fastest way to remove your seasoned coating) and the coating can be scratched off, particularly at the edges when scraped along other objects.

Honestly, I really like these steels for pizza/sourdoughs, but since EVERYONE shows that capability, I thought I'd show you some french "milk bread" baguettes I baked on these steels. I've also included a picture of the BOTTOM of a loaf, cooked at 215C for 25 minutes on the pre-heated steel. It's dark, but not burnt and despite being a softer loaf, I think the crust (and crumb) came out pretty much perfectly.

I've baked with these steels on several occasions now, and they fit in my oven, they work well, need the same care as most steels, and come delivered at the most affordable price I could find. What more can you ask for?

 Follow-up  · Three questions that have been asked since I wrote my review are: 1. HOW EASY IS THE STEEL TO CLEAN? Firstly, NEVER put seasoned cookware in the dishwasher, it'll strip the seasoning right off,(detergents are excellent for getting rid of grease and oil.... and that's exactly what seasoning is). If you do put it in the dishwasher, the seasoning will be removed, the metal will start to rust immediately, and you'll have to rebuild the seasoning up fro scratch. In short, no seasoned metal is dishwasher safe. This is a seasoned piece of steel, which, if seasoned properly, is basically multiple thin layers of baked-on oil, over a smooth plate of steel, forming a non-stick surface. Given the smoothness of the steel compared to the grainy texture of cast iron, it can be easier to clean than seasoned cast iron. However, just like seasoned cast iron... if the seasoning is done in thicker coats, that can render a slightly tacky/sticky result which makes things quite a bit harder to clean up. Similarly, if the seasoned coating is compromised, or deteriorated, it'll take a lot more to clean up. Maintenance is much less effort than repair! When the steel is seasoned properly, I just wipe off any flour/pizza toppings off once the steel has cooled down with a soft, damp cloth, give it a light rinse with warm water, and if that doesn't work, very lightly soapy water (the detergent will eat your seasoning so avoid it as much as possible). Then I bake it at 100C for 15 minutes to dry it completely, and I let it cool. I probably add 1-2 coats to my cookware two or three times a year. I have two steels, two cast iron loaf pans, and a few cast iron barbecue plates/griddles. If they're clean, I simply dust them off with a quick rinse, heat it to 200C or so wipe a THIN and even layer of oil all over the pan, wiping any excess off, bake it for and hour and let it cool naturally. Assess and repeat. It will get smoky in your kitchen though. You're effectively burning oil onto your cookware after all. 2. HOW DOES THE STEEL AFFECT BAKING TIME? Obviously, the steel needs to be preheated before baking. I usually start to do that 35-45 mins (45 mins if I'm heating two steels) before the bake because this steel is comparably thick to most cast iron loaf pans. I often bake at temperatures ranging from 225-270C.. however your oven will dictate the time needed for heat up. If you're cooking at one temp throughout the bake (like pizza), then the steel does not impact the baking time. However if you start high and then reduce it (like when cooking breads), I shorten the high temp component by a 1-5 minutes (depending on the thickness/height of the bread, and the difference in new lower temperature) to allow for the steel's lag in cooling down. For the second part, I usually keep the lower temp bake a similar length of time to the recipe, and check in on it 5-7 minutes from the end and assess what needs to be done. I'm sorry, but there's no "one magic number" solution here. So I've kept my advice as general and adaptable as possible. 3. HOW DOES THE STEEL HANDLE HIGHER TEMPERATURES? This is the easy answer. Seasoned gear goes higher than any enamelled dutch oven because there's no enamel/glass coatings to crack, no plastic handles to melt. The underlying metals can EASILY handle temperatures of any oven you'd likely use. That said, steels start being tempered as low as 160C, but fortunately the lower end of that range generally reduces brittleness and relieves internal stresses. Going between 200-300C, well it depends on the exact steel composition, but not a lot happens. If seasoned and maintained properly, I have taken my seasoned pans/steels to 320C in my barbecue and that worked fine. That's more than enough to bake any bread/pizza I can think of (most bread recipes top out at 250-280C), and pizza is usually baked for <15 minutes, typically between 270-300 Celsius for that extra crispy base and melted toppings. If you're going 300C+ with your seasoned cookware, I'd recommend using an oil with a higher smoke point (although once the seasoning is polymerised through being baked on, the choice of oil becomes largely moot). I use grape seed oil because of it's extremely neutral flavour, and it's a little less sticky, even if the seasoning isn't perfect on the first/second coat. However, many other oils have a higher range smoke points (and the more refined the oil is, the higher the smoke point tends to be). If you do manage to scrape/burn off your seasoning, simply give it a couple of extra coats. Unless it's flaky or patchy, then you're probably better off starting from scratch once again.

ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.