Review your last buy on ProductReview.com.au
5Braemar Ecostar Ducted Gas TQ Series

Braemar Ecostar Ducted Gas TQ Series

 Verified
5Braemar Ecostar Ducted Gas TQ Series
2.5

116 reviews

Positive vs Negative
27%5%68%
Heating Speed1/5 - 5/5
Smells of GasYes · No
Build Quality
2.4
Value for Money
2.3
Noise Level
2.7
Temperature Consistency
3.2
Safety
3.1
5 Disappointed user  · Very efficient and saved on gas bills, thank you again
5 Nicole C.  · So quiet, great heating, very effective quickly heating an open plan lounge dining kitchen area. Love this unit, fits into the roof highly recommend.
5 Darren  · Works really good & is quite to run. Heats up the whole house quickly
5 John Harrison  · Unit operates as expected, running costs are fair, heats whole of house as designed layout of ducting sends warm air through out the residence effectively.
5 Darryl Gibson  · At the time the unit was excellent but we know longer own the place we purchased it for.
5 John  · We are very pleased with the ducted heating, it is easy to control & we have had no issues with it.&
Fetch
FetchVIC2 posts
  Verified Ecostar TQ425

The short answer is excellent it works well ,is very quiet and the controller and is so easy to use . The only negative is the ceiling outlest vents are not as good as our old units floor vents,especially standing over them in winter,but we had no sub floor room for the larger ducting it just means the room takes a little longer to fully saturated. We have only had one winter but sofar very happy Show details ·  1

Ask the reviewer
Raymond M.
Raymond M.2 posts
  Verified Ecostar TQM618
Noise Level
Heating Speed
Temperature Consistency

Had the unit installed back in 2016, it was serviced every two years and was working fine until 2024 when it started showing error 39 and 47 combustion pressure sensor had the motherboard cost over $750, only for the same problem to happen this year part cost over $450 will be replaced on Thursday. Avoid this heater or Baemer heaters altogether. Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience.… Read more (+1 reply)

Ask the reviewer
Sparrow
Sparrow5 posts
  Verified Ecostar TQ325

Had a Braemar TQ325 installed in roof space 6 weeks ago to replace another heater that had reached the end of its service life. The unit is noisy when running with a constant deep drone like sound, that can be heard above the TV when on. The unit also does not heat the area effectively, frequently switching on and off even though doors and windows… Read more

are shut. It also switches off below the set temperature on the thermostat. Have not yet had a gas or electricty account to assess running costs.

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Sparrow, thanks for sharing this and I’m sorry your… Read more (+3 replies)

Positive reviews

ro-tax
ro-taxVIC2 posts
  Ecostar TQ425

I have only had the Tq425 for a week but we are very impressed on how quickly and effortlessly the rooms come up to temp and i can zone the far end of the house on or off to suit kids or no kids home. There is Only 2 zones available, We fitted 10 outlets in a 20 Sq home. 2 Bathrooms, 4 bedrooms ect done but that suits us. I can just hear the… Read more ·  1

heater operating in the roof but if there is other noise like tv or kids you wont notice it, Its like light rain on the roof. So far so good, 6K fitted in Vic. Very happy. :)

Bax
BaxVIC3 posts
  3 Star Series
Value for Money
Noise Level
Heating Speed
Temperature Consistency

Long enough service to deserve a medal – Couldn't find the exact model. After a fairly rocky start, (with a few issues with what was a new product at the time) this TM200 has been near faultless for 25yrs, just recently has needed resetting on a regular basis, but let's be honest it's a pretty good run. I'm about to replace it with another updated model. Show details ·  1

Franz102
Franz1022 posts
  Ecostar TQ320

Great heater – New model TQ320 is a great cheap to run heater. What’s the house instantly, very happy. Quick installation time and turn around. Would recommend for anybody looking to change over or install a new heater Show details ·  1

Negative reviews

Jim
Jim
  Verified Ecostar TQ420

gas valve is faulty about a week before the 5 year warranty is due to expire. installer says that because the unit wasn't serviced the warranty is voided - be careful when buying anything from braemar because they will get you with their terrible warranty terms and poor product quality. Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Jim, Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry… Read more

aussie43
aussie439 posts
  Verified Ecostar TQM5X30
Value for Money
Noise Level
Heating Speed
Safety

The heater does the job, however - 1. The box is designed to be universal - for internal and external installation. It is very small and the paper-thin metal walls have no insulation. The main heat exchanger is no more than an inch from the metal wall and the wall is too hot to touch. I can't believe that this product could score 5 stars. My… Read more

installation is external, and I would be hesitant to put this heater in the roof. The exhaust gas is hot also, but that is a different story and I expected that.

2. The "M" in TQM stands for modulation. When the room temperature approaches the set temperature, the brochure says that the heat output is reduced (modulated) to keep the heater running longer. The result is longer OFF/ON cycles, and more comfortable outcome. However I have not experienced any of this. The heater status on the screen shows the same thermistor temperature and fan speed all the time to the point when the heater switches off. The air coming out of the registers is also hot all the way to the off point. Depending on the max gas rate setting, it could be well over 50°C. And I haven't run the heater on 100% heat output yet! I would expect that with proper modulation, the air coming into the room would be just a bit warmer than the set temperature once the set temperature is reached. I would say that the "M" is an advertising gimmick, and if it is there at all, it is ineffective.

3. The Set Point differential on this system - the heater and the controller - is too wide. And it is not adjustable! I miss my old retired (American Lennox) system where I could set 0.5°C differential. With this Braemar system, if I set 22°C, the heater will reach 23°C and keep running for a while, before it switches off. It will not switch on again until the temperature falls to 21°C and keeps there for a while. The temperature difference is noticeable and I don't find this very comfortable.

I will also point to something that do like, and what was the reason why I selected Braemar - it is the ability of the User to select heat output - 25%, 50%, 75%, 100% - and fan speed on the MagIQtouch controller. The controller is very intuitive, and one can operate the system (I also have the add-on cooling) without having to learn anything. I would score 4 and 1/2 for the controller alone. I do not have the Wi-Fi option, but would get it if Braemar regularly updated the system firmware and made updates available to users.

aussie43
aussie43   

Edit: Regarding my Point #2 : After more experience in colder weather, I have noticed that the… Read more (+2 replies)

Blue Outlander
Blue OutlanderVIC9 posts
  Ecostar TQ420
Noise Level
Heating Speed
Temperature Consistency
Safety

Braemar is unreliable and price needs to include service fees!!! to keep warranty – Got this unit installed to replace my 20 year old ducted heater during April 2021 - and its showing an ignition fault already. Totally unreliable!! Also they should have added the required service fees every 2 years to the price!!! As you need them to keep your warranty. I would have bought something else if i knew that. Totally duped with the price and reliability!!! Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi there, as part of the warranty terms and conditions,… Read more (+4 replies)

Recent reviews

Ardy
Ardy6 posts
  Ecostar TQM5X20
Build Quality
Value for Money
Temperature Consistency
Safety

very expensive – Hi, I moved into a new home in February and used the aircon which worked fine. During winter switched to heating only to have my first gas bill at 559 for a MONTH which I assumed was due to a gas log heater I had installed. I changed suppliers. This week I discovered that I had a Braemar TQM5X2 space gas heater in the roof space that uses 88mj… Read more

hr., I thought I was using reverse cycle air con. The unit works well but the cost of running it is exorbitant 88Mj at 0.03c a Mj = $2.64 per hr x 6hrs a day = $21.12 per day x 30 days =$633 per month.

Braemar
Braemar    

Thank you for your feedback regarding your Braemar TQM5X2… Read more (+1 reply)

Chris K.
Chris K.
  Ecostar TQS730

Terrible...avoid! – Do not install this system. We installed the 7 star system about 4 years ago in our home in NZ. We have had nothing but issues with it and regret spending >NZ$20k on this system. We have had 4 separate call outs due to faults. Thankfully, most of these were covered by the warranty, however, that last one was rejected as we missed a service by a… Read more

couple of months, so now we have no warranty at all. The last fault was a faulty MagicTouch screen, so nothing at all to do with the gas system or missing a service, NZ$800 to install a new control screen! Luckily for us the local company which services the units took the hit on the screen install, just sucks that Seely didn't come to the party on this. The system is extremely loud, like a jet engine. We've had the techs look at it and see if they can make it quieter, without success. When we installed it we only put heating in, we've subsequently looked to have the cooling added but won't be doing this as it is ridiculously expensive to do so (NZ$16k to add cooling to an existing system). Biggest regret of our renovation. Stay away from this system.

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Chris, sorry to hear you've had some ongoing issues… Read more

Aria
AriaVIC3 posts
  Verified Ecostar TQ516

Absolute unprofessional customer service – I just had a horrific unprofessional experience with one of their customer service staff not listening to my inquiries properly regarding the warranty on my heater, constantly interupting me and threating to end the call with an aggressive raised tone and also refusing to put me through to a supervisor. I did not have my questions answered and… Read more

being told the warranty was expired back in April whereas the unit was installed in July so supposedly the warranty should also end in a July month. As for the quality of their repairs, the unit started showing the same symptoms of Ignition issues only after a year of use. To be fair the unit worked a few years within warranty period with minimal usage which probably deserves a bit more than 1 star however I wouldn't have even bothered purchasing it knowing I would be treated in such disrespectful manner by their team later on.

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Aria, sorry to hear you had an unsatisfactory… Read more

Gas Heaters

Find out how Braemar Ecostar Ducted Gas TQ Series compares to other Gas Heaters

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
Peter J.
Peter J.VIC
  Ecostar TQ320

A total waste of money – This unit is complete junk. The worst $3500 i have spent. The unit ran well for 2 months until the problems began, and always the same problem: The heater runs its first heat cycle, then fails to reignite. Only a power reset will enable it to start, which given the unit is in my roof is less than ideal. The previous unit (a Brivis) was almost… Read more

silent, This thing is incredibly noisy. I have had 15 service calls and it has not been fixed. Still exactly the same problem.

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Peter I'm sorry to hear you've had some ongoing issues… Read more (+1 reply)

jan
janVIC9 posts
  5 Star Series

MagIQtouch control unit - needs technician when change batteries – When it works the gas furnace is wonderful BUT every 2 years you have to replace batteries in control unit leading to technician call out at $300+ to reconnect wireless controller to gas furnace The provider user manual doesn’t match installed product Reminds me of the American engineering in American cars My previous Brivis unit worked for 31 without a service call Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Jan, we are disappointed to see your 1 star review for… Read more (+2 replies)

Kathy V
Kathy VVIC5 posts
  Ecostar TQ523
Noise Level
Heating Speed
Temperature Consistency
Safety

this Ecostar is no star! just a piece of expensive junk – we had this 5 star Ecostar ducted heating model installed 5 years ago and it has been nothing but trouble since the beginning. I have had to call out for repairs every winter since its installation in 2018! It has gone through so many fault detections and this year im on call out no 2 within 2 months!! It cost more than $2.5k to purchaser and Im… Read more

now out of pocket $1k for this call out to fix the latest faults because its out of warranty! ofcourse! I have tried to contact Sealy Interantional about their very faulty machine but they are MIA! Never get a reply! great work Braemer!! you know how to produce expensive heating junk for landfill!! dont waste your money on this % star Ecostar! its no star! just expensive junk metal!! thanks for nothing braemer/seally international!!! :(:(:(

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Kathy, we are so sorry to hear that you've been having… Read more (+2 replies)

Tyccc
Tyccc3 posts
  Ecostar TQ435

Slow and chews your gas bill – Received my gas bill for the last 2 months and it came to $526 which is absolutely ridiculous. The gas heater is on maximum 2-3 hrs a day. Not only that, it will take 5+ hrs to heat from. 10 to 20 degrees. Spoke to a technician and he said it was normal which is nonsense. Stay away from Braemar Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi there, sorry to hear you were disappointed with your… Read more (+4 replies)

Peter G.
Peter G.16 posts
  Ecostar TQM632
Build Quality
Noise Level
Heating Speed
Temperature Consistency
Safety

Fails to ignite specially in the morning, when is cold, when is most needed. Repeated resets lead to SYS OFF – BRAEMAR TQM6 - Absolutely frustrating. After many many services and attempts to fix, by four different experts gas plumbers, thousands spent, still no solution. The last local Braemar expert can't explain why the system displays error codes like 06, 07, 51, and today 21 with no logical lead. So he concluded now for the 2nd time in 5 years it is… Read more

the circuit board. But why the inconsistency of error codes? So according to him, it must be the ICE, cost including install $ 720,00!!!

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Peter, sorry to hear about the issues you've been… Read more (+2 replies)

Salim B.
Salim B.VIC
  Verified Ecostar TQ430
Noise Level
Heating Speed
Temperature Consistency

save your money. unit fails every year since installed 2019 – Installed braemar TQ430 to replaced a 20 year old unit. The unit fails at least twice every year since install. Failed again this year with same issue and winter just started. they sent same service man eveytime but he refuses to tell us or show us which part is replaced. he doesn't even have a tool box when he goes in the roof to check for fault. avoid this brand. Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Salim, can you please send your full name, contact… Read more

Joe C.
Joe C.Victoria2 posts
  Verified Ecostar Ducted Gas TQ Series

Absolute garbage – Heats well when working unfortunately it’s not working very often. This hunk of junk is barely 3 years old and has only done 3 winters but continues to switch off automatically. The only way to get it going again switch the power off for 10 minutes to reset the unit. I’ve had techs look at it time and time again costing money for service and have… Read more

no result. Obviously Braemar don’t want anything to do with it after having chats personally with them and promises to return phone calls. They can’t even honor their crappy product. To be honest if I could rate it less than a 1 star I would. Do yourselves a favor save your money and stay away.

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Joe, this seems very unusual that someone from Seeley… Read more

Lucky Phil
Lucky PhilVIC3 posts
  Ecostar TQ330

Braemar TQ330 Gas ducted heater – Replaced a 10 year old Brivis 2P Wombat. $4290 which did not include a programmable Thermostat. So paid an extra $434 for a Honeywell FocusPRO 6000 thermostat. The heater heats well except that it is noisy and cycles on and off until it reaches the required temperature. It should be operating continuously at a slower speed and lower noise until it reaches temperature. This is a bad design fault. Can this be changed? Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Phil, thank you for your review. If you still need… Read more

petti
pettiVIC2 posts
  Ecostar TQ420

Most disgusted – Had new Braemar Ecostar ducted heater installed last month and installer out 5 times already!!! The unit does not warm house adequately. It takes approx. 5 hrs to reach desired temperature-turning off every 3minutes. Further noise level is LOUD. My old unit was so quiet you did not even know the heater was on. I had to replace it as it eventually… Read more

died. This new one is not worth any money at all. It is loud and inadequate. It's almost like being in industrial setting or airport.. Soooo annoying and does not even work properly in a speedy time. Very uncomfortable to be in the cold house due to poor heating and the place is small. Do not buy Braemar Ecostar .. Definately not value for money and I will definately replace this unit even though it's new.. The installer stated nothing else can be done as the unit is under warranty and any changes to the unit would detract from factory settings and therefore void the warranty..

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Petti, we would like to help you further with this… Read more

Gas Heaters

Find out how Braemar Ecostar Ducted Gas TQ Series compares to other Gas Heaters

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
Greg. Korumburra
Greg. KorumburraVIC
  Ecostar TQM520

THIS UNIT CANNOT HANDLE COLD WEATHER!!!! – Had my TQ520 heating system installed new into my fully insulated house in April 2017. Every winter since installation, when the morning temperature outside is below 10, this unit will start and stop intermittently (in approx 3 minute cycles) until the house temp reaches 15.....only then does it keep running. So, consequently, the house is cold… Read more

for most of the day. We set the thermostat for 17 daytime temp but the heater has trouble even achieving this . This has been the situation every year since installation , and the filter is checked and cleaned very regularly.

My local service agent, "Precision Heating" in Vic has been called many times(10 times in 5 years, not including regular servicing) and tried many fixes but still can't solve the problem.

Tried calling Seeley but they clearly don't care, much less return you calls....they are of absolutely no assistance at all and do not support their product.

Best advice is .... don't install one of these pathetic excuses for a central heating system.

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Greg, as you will see I also responded to your private… Read more

Kevin B.
Kevin B.VIC
  Ecostar TQ320

Takes ages to heat the house – Takes ages to heat the house, told this would be more efficient but frankly it’s the worst heater we’ve ever had. Our previous unit heated the whole house up to temp within an hour, this piece of crap take 3 -4 hours + to elevate temp from approx 14 to 18 degrees. To be balanced, starts every time when switched on which saves on eliminating the pilot lights continuously burning. These are the only positives I can say. Very disappointed. Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Kevin, did you ask the installer to come and check the… Read more

Brian N
Brian NVIC2 posts
  Ecostar TQM5X20

Four breakdowns under warranty in 12 months – We have been renting a house while we build a new place, and one of these heaters was installed new not long before we moved in. When it's working it heats well, although it is noisy. However it has failed four times in 12 months, and has had to have a new gas valve and two new igniters. All done under warranty, and service was fine, but the large number of negative reviews suggests that it may not be the most reliable system out there. Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi Brian, sorry to hear you've had some issues with your… Read more

George B.
George B.VIC2 posts
  Ecostar TQ320

Breamar TQ320NG – For the last 2 weeks my 5 years old unit turns off by itself after 4 - 8 hours of working. Experts do not know what is wrong with it. Suggested buying different brand. Show details

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi George, if you are still having issues and need… Read more

kezz
kezzVIC40 posts
  Verified Ecostar TQM530
Build Quality
Value for Money
Noise Level
Heating Speed
Temperature Consistency

Disappointed - temperature differences between floors – In May 2020, I replaced my existing ducted heating system with a new Braemar TQM530 Gas Ducted Heater which was installed by Smarter Heating and Cooling. This review will be about the appliance and I will write a separate review about the installation, which has caused problems with temperature distribution. The good - Operates well, no… Read more

mechanical problems - Heats a large area fairly quickly - I love the fan-only feature to circulate air - Comes with a remote control unit that includes a timer

The bad - The controller is fairly fragile. - Zoned heating could not installed because it was a retrofit. This means that if I want to use heating, I have to heat the whole house, including rooms that are not in use (kids leaving home). - Wifi control via an app was additional and the installer said it was not worth it. This was disappointing as it was a key feature in my selection. - Although the unit has various fan speed settings, I have been advised not to use this feature as running at reduced capacity damages the unit. - Although the vents can be closed, I have been strongly advised not to do that as it also causes damage to the unit. I may have to do it anyway because of my problem with temperature differences. - It's a bit noisy

I selected this heater because it had a range of features that sounded great. I was looking forward to getting a greener, more efficient and more modern system. Unfortunately because it was being retro-fitted and the house, has two stories, some of these features were not available. This wasn't communicated to me until quite late in the process, and I think I probably would have been better to consider a cheaper, less sophisticated unit.

I have also had significant problems with temperature differences between the upper and lower floors because it was installed with most vents upstairs.

In conclusion, while the unit appears to be mechanically sound, if I had I known that I would not have been able to get zoned heating and that I would have so much trouble with temperature differences, I may have made different decisions.

T P
T PVIC10 posts
  4 Star Series

VERY bad branch & service – We bought the unit 4/2021 from ColdFlow. Soon we found it did not work properly : stopping every few minutes & LITTLE WARMING. The company said it should be OK. Now in April, 2022. NOT WARMING AT ALL. Keeping run for 5 hours WITHOUT heating ( no errors nor orange color on number to show it worked. BUT BLACK... Coldflow called them 3 time NO… Read more

RESPONSE. Today 12/04/2022, Braemar called back & said a service man would be anytime from 8-5PM.........!!!!!!. Her voice asked if we are BEGGARS.....

Braemar
Braemar    

Hi T, sorry to hear you've had some issues with your… Read more

Tom
TomVIC24 posts
  Ecostar TQ4X30+
Noise Level
Heating Speed
Temperature Consistency
Safety

Avoid, (Braemar) if you have a choice – Product installed in 1/Jan/2017. The installation gave up its ghost on 20th Feb 2022. The motor on the product TQ4x30 burnt out - less than 2 months outside of its proclaimed 5-year warranty. Darebin gas was recommended by the company (Seeley) to service the unit. Replacing the motor cost me $660. Darebin gas, I would give 5 stars for the… Read more

service, they (Garry) were prompt, efficient and did the job at the agreed date and time. Thank you.

Note this fine print for warranty claims: To be eligible for the 7-year warranty, the product has to be: 1. installed by their "special agents" (or you will not get the 7-year warranty, but you will get 5 years.) 2. serviced by their "special agents" at 2 and 4 years" or you will not get the 5 or 7-year warranty.

Those who 'new build' their homes and have this product installed, please ask your builder/installer for the paperwork for all appliances installed, so you can read the fine print.

The unit worked ok for 5 years, just very disappointed that it had to go kaput just under two months outside of the warranty (which I would not be eligible for, because I did not service the unit as per their requirements, that I was not aware of.)

I would expect products of this nature to last a lot longer than 5 years.

Aspasia T.
Aspasia T.VIC
  Ecostar TQ415

So noisy – Had unit installed last month to replace my 10 year old heater. It heats well but it’s so noisey. You can hear the clicking when it turns on/off and the fan sounds like an aeroplane propeller getting ready for take off. It’s anything but whisper quiet as advertised in their brochure. Show details

ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.