527 reviews
The Federal Court has found that Choosi Pty Ltd misled consumers in relation to its funeral and life insurance comparison services. The Court found that Choosi made representations to consumers that conveyed it compared products from a range of funeral and life insurers. However, in respect of funeral insurance, from 1 July 2019, Choosi only… Read more
compared policies issued by a single insurer, Hannover Life Re of Australasia Ltd. In respect of life insurance, from 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2023, Choosi only compared policies issued by Hannover and a single policy issued by Swiss Re Life & Health Australia. From 1 July 2023, all life insurance policies Choosi compared were issued by Hannover. All policies were distributed by Greenstone Financial Services Pty Ltd, a company associated with Choosi.
ASIC alleged that 4,225 Hannover funeral insurance policies and 9,478 Hannover life insurance policies were sold through Choosi’s comparison service between 1 July 2019 and 30 November 2024.
ASIC Chair Sarah Court said the Court upheld ASIC's concerns that consumers seeking to compare insurance products to find the best price were misled about the choices available to them.
‘Consumers deserve clear and accurate information about how comparison services operate and the products they do, or do not, compare.
‘Businesses cannot create the impression that they offer consumers genuine choice from a range of products when that choice does not exist.
‘At a time when many Australians are looking for the best value products, misleading consumers about the range of products being compared may undermine their ability to make informed financial decisions.
‘This outcome sends a strong message that businesses must be transparent about the products they compare and the choices they offer consumers.’
ASIC alleged that Choosi's website, advertising, and promotional materials conveyed that consumers could compare funeral and life insurance policies from a range of insurers, when the products compared were overwhelmingly sourced from a single insurer and distributed by a related entity.
In delivering judgment, Justice Anderson said, ‘Through the Choosi Website, and each of the impugned advertising materials, Choosi falsely gave consumers the impression that its Comparison Service compared policies from a broader range of insurers than it in fact did’.
‘...[T]he repeated emphasis throughout the Choosi Website and advertising materials was that Choosi would save consumers time and effort, do the hard work of comparing policies, simplify an otherwise complex process, and assist consumers to make an informed choice. The premise underlying those statements is that the consumer is receiving the benefit of a meaningful comparison across the available market. Consumers, generally speaking, use comparison services because they offer an efficient substitute for consumers undertaking lengthy research themselves across many platforms, in this case saving consumers from approaching insurers individually. A reasonable consumer would, therefore, understand references to a “range” of insurers as conveying that the service surveys a meaningful selection of insurers available in the market, rather than merely two insurers. The comparative value of such a service derives, at least in substantial part, from the breadth of the market being surveyed,’ Justice Anderson said.
The matter will return to the Court on a date to be determined for submissions on penalty and other relief sought by ASIC.
Reviews with attachments
Bundy – Fantastic service I feel very happy with how everything was explained in detail very clear and precise. Cathrine was very knowledgeable giving me confidence in the coverage I chose I’m very happy for piece of mind. Pic of Bundy Show reply
Pet Insurance and Exemptions – I have a puppy!!... A Chocolate Labrador, so I needed insurance - they eat EVERYTHING! lol. I was having problems choosing an insurance but the exemptions did not cover genetic hip and leg issues, which is a risk for the breed. Choosi rang me... A Brilliant staff member rang me, i was struggling online.. he spent ages with me checking all the fine… Read more · 1
print exemptions. In the end I got the right insurance (RSCPA) and he saved me $700 from my original choice!. Thank you very good service.
Latest follow-ups
Abit long winded, however all necessary. All info provided in an easily understood manner. Show 2 replies
Follow-up · Service team very helpful for renewal. Policy price very competitive v other insurers. Renewal process was very easy.
Positive reviews
Helpful person spoke clearly and explained everything nicely. Well done Show reply
My experience with the CSO was awesome explained everything clearly and I was confident to purchase what I needed. Show reply
Loved the ease and professionalism of the consultant. Keep up the good work Show reply
Negative reviews
Hopeless website. Automatically gives your details to a cold calling center.
Unless you want to do all the hard work online, these guys are of zero help. Don't even have insurance agents you can speak with over the phone to compare.
Hi Tim, We’re sorry to hear your experience wasn’t what… Read more
Looks bad for Choosi which is currently in the Federal court of Australia facing ASIC charged with misleading consumers by only quoting insurance from companies / brands owned by its own owner. ASIC is alleging Hannover paid Choosi about $61 million in commissions since 2019 to solely advertise products from its company on the comparison website.
Hi there, Choosi as a platform compares products from… Read more (+2 replies)
Recent reviews
Very helpfull takes time to explain things good at customer help Show reply
The operator was very helpful. The whole process was seamless Show reply
Find out how Choosi compares to other Insurance Comparison Websites
Know better, choose better.
Maggie was friendly and informative, and followed up as planned. Show reply
helpful listened to my boundaries and requirements and didn’t mess me around. i recommend Dominic the gentleman who dealt with me Show reply
Excellent customer service provided by the consultant. Really good and honest service Show reply
Very very helpful and gave me very good advice. Thank you for all your help today Show reply
Thank you, Kevin's assistance was valuable help to insure the choice I made was correct for myself. Show reply
Very informative and very professional, very easy quick to call Show reply
Was a good agent but he talks to much, he dosn't take a breath. Show reply
Very good and experienced people to work with excellent staff in this industry Show reply
Absolutely happy to what I was offered, even though I didn't get what I wanted but still happy Show 2 replies
Find out how Choosi compares to other Insurance Comparison Websites
Know better, choose better.
Very friendly staff that clearly state what is going to happen. Very professional and took time to understand. Show reply
The person I spoke to was extremely knowledgeable, helpful and patient with me. Thanks for that. I would recommend Choosi to my friends. Show reply
Kap was very clear and understandable, and very patient as interrupted him several times. Thank you for your patience Kap Show reply
To speedy responding – Very fast getting in touch with me. I was still on line looking at my options when I received a call. I didn’t have time to check the information and felt bombarded. I would have preferred time look at the different products. The bottom line is that I most likely would have made the same decision, but I was overwhelmed with all the information without time to think and felt pressured. Show 3 replies
Great experience – The operator was fantastic and made it so easy to choose. Show reply
Exemplary customer service – Called back at an agreed time and provided excellent customer service including working through the policies. Show reply
Funeral Insurance – Very clear and concise and objective when it came to discussing the best produce for our needs. Show reply
Could be better - listen up UX designers – This site could be better. The form was fine, but it would be good to see what is available as I go and as I answer questions, options disappear until I'm left with my final few. This would enable me to go back and adjust things to make compromises on what's important to get the insurer and price I want. A lot of other comparison websites have it… Read more
already in the form of tables and filters. Have both the form and that table and you'll do much better
Hi Campbell, Thank you for taking the time to share your… Read more
Great – Very easy to understand and customer service was helpful & friendly Show reply
Excellent – Very polite and friendly man, I would definitely deal with Choosing again. Show reply
Pet Insurance – Brittany, was gr8 to deal with definitely 10/10! Highly recommend her! Show reply
Hi there, Thank you for sharing your review with us, we… Read more (+1 reply)