118 reviews
- Yes, but have not reached my goal weight yet
- ·
- Yes, I have reached my goal weight
- ·
- Yes, I have exceeded my goal weight
- ·
- My weight has stayed the same
- ·
- I have gained weight
Been almost 4 weeks since ordering this product with no delivery. Why advertise a product if you have no stock and can't deliver when someone orders. I'd give zero if I could. Looks like this company is holding people's money without delivering anything. I'd avoid like the plague.
The Cookie Diet is everything you’re supposed to reject: Ultra-processed, mystery ingredients Chronic under-eating (1,000–1,200 kcal/day) Relies on fake satiety tricks (fiber + “proprietary” proteins) Blood sugar rollercoasters from 8g+ carbs per cookie, eaten 6–9 times/day Zero respect for biological needs, hormone stability, or long-term sustainability It’s the antithesis of our ancestrally appropriate diet: carnivore Show details
I have just started this diet and hoping I didn’t waste my money buying 3 months worth, so far Not a fan of the chocolate brownie the other flavours or better slightly too sweet I wish you had the Parmesan and sun-dried tomatoes in the variety packs, but I am not a fan of them being dry and stale tasting but on saying that I will give it a go for… Read more
at least a month and see how I go! Oh yeah I also bought the scales thinking having a digital pair would be great but connecting them through the app was easy put in all my details weighed myself then says it can’t add data, it tells me to take my shoes off I’m usually naked or check I have put in my details correctly, I think I know my age, height or even sex and if that doesn’t work try different floors in the house I have tried every room in the house and unless I’m going to try them outside on the concrete and scare my neighbours with my naked body, it doesn’t work like they are meant too!
Reviews with attachments
Surprised- it works !! – Very happy and surprised how easy it’s been. Gets a bit boring eating the same thing all the time and I really enjoy eating my real food on an evening but it’s working and somehow suppresses my big appetite. Show reply
Excellent – Perfect diet plan to carry on with my busy life… I love it Show reply
- +5
Making Dieting Easy – Very happy, 4.5 kg lost in less than 3 weeks. 5kg to go. Cookies are yummy, I usually don't eat cookies, they fulfil my sweet cravings and suppress my hunger. Diet that I can actually stick to. I exercise daily which also helps. I have just placed another order for another month :) Show details · 1
This has been the perfect diet during lockdown – I’ve been using the Cookie Diet as a snack, in between my meals. So instead of reaching for that unhealthy 3pm snack, I now can count my calories, which has helped me lose a few extra kg. I’ve also recommended it to two of my friends and they’ve both lost 4kg each in the first week!! Show details · 1
In-depth reviews
Why the change in SIZE !! – 2024- My 1st two months supply ..loved them ,,there roughy looking cookie & size...all tasted Good !! Then the 3rd bunch arrived ..2 or the 4 were smaller and exact proportions .Went and read some reviews to the commpany In Australia making them ..That person got an answer of --they go by weight ,,if the look smaller , they are more densed-well I… Read more
weighed mine and both sizes were different in weight . So I emailed the HQ in Australia and their reply was --We are using a new Baker, to keep every cookie uniformed !...Well they are difintely smaller now and taste different . I sense that the company here in AUS land are trying to get every last cent out of production and make them all smaller and Uniformed , no odd shaped tops as they use to be ..I just liked their size before and irregular shapes , but they are WAY smaller now and the taste has changed ..Ummmm don't know what to do !! Don't get me wrong ..THEY work ..it's just --Looking at the size now and my Tummy says ---IS THAT ALL YOUR GOING TO GIVE ME !!....IMO....It's you decision !
Happy with the results so far – I started my cookie diet 2 weeks ago. I was skeptical at first as I couldn't see how a nice tasting biscuit could help with weight loss. The first 4 days were good and by 5pm I was well and truly hungry for Dinner. By day 5 I found that I wasn't that hungry in afternoon as I had been previously. My only failure was I didn't eat the 9 cookies a… Read more · 1
day. I started with 2 at 8am followed by 1 at 10am 1 at 12pm and 2 at 1pm. The 3 ,5 and 9pm ones I tended to miss as I was busy.
After reading everyone's comments and checking the cookie website I realise that I needed to eat the 9 biscuits a day. I also wasn't drinking enough water. So finally after 2 weeks even though I didn't feel as though I'd lost any weight I weighed myself and was very pleased to see that I had lost 5.7kg. I had done no exercise in that time and even broke the diet once or twice, because I just felt like eggs on toast for breakfast and of course a sandwich for lunch. I bought 2 months supply and it's probably one of the best things I've done for myself in a long time. My hardest challenge is not being tempted by food when I have to cook meals for my family.
Dr siegal cookie diet – I've got to say I've been on many diets the last 20 years ..this is the only one I have been successful with.. I was extremely unwell I have been on this diet for three weeks ..the week I started the difference was huge to my general health.. I was bordering death I would say the doctors gave up on me I had mysterious illnesses I couldn't breathe… Read more · 1
I couldn't walk without sticks or my wheelchair.. life was very hard within three days I started to breathe within 5 days I did not have to use my chair or my sticks I have lost 7 kilos in 3 weeks and my life has now changed at least 80% if not more I would recommend this diet to anybody.. my general practitioner could not believe the health difference that these biscuits made to my life she said do not go off them for at least three months because you may go back and I said don't worry I won't go off them and I love them.. my doctor wants to keep an eye on me because she said that she wants to be able to recommend them to clients she was that impressed and she does not get impressed with much believe you me.
Positive reviews
I love these cookies! – I love these cookies! I’ve tried a few programmes before, and while I did lose weight with them, I got bored of the flavours. I started with their 1-week cookies package, and after just a few days, I upgraded to their 1-month variety supply. The different flavours really help break up the monotony, and surprisingly, I feel full after just two cookies. Show details · 1
Sounds crazy, Actually works! – Tastes great - really helped me lose weight, and now I use these as a snack to tired me over between meals! Cookie Diet... sounds crazy, actually works! Show reply
Find out how Cookie Diet compares to other Diet & Weight Loss Programs
Know better, choose better.
Amazing – It actually works! After umming about it all before, I was concerned that this would work. but super easy to incorporate into my life and the lbs fell off. Never felt better. It also helps that the cookies taste amazing. Show reply
Negative reviews
"This company spends heavily on advertising and fake reviews. These biscuits do not work—don’t waste your money. When I requested a refund, they said they couldn’t refund just because it didn’t work for me. A COMPLETE WASTE OF MONEY. " Show details
Product Size Decrease – I have been eating the cookies since 2022 and must admit they do work with weight loss if you stick to the instructions. However, when I received my last order the cookies had dramatically decreased in size and had changed shape but cost had increased. I don't feel like they are as nice as they used to be which is a shame as I finally thought I… Read more
had found a diet that suited me. I have even been short changed biscuits as there are supposed to be nine in each tray and often I only receive 8. Now that the size has decreased they do not even fill the trays and when I weighed them against the original cookies they weighed less. This makes me wonder if they will still be as effective as they were?
Hi Sandra, Thank you for sharing your feedback, and… Read more
Newbie – Ordered the variety pack (all four flavours). The box arrived with 3 x Oatmeal and 1 x Chocolate. I immediately emailed and got an immediate response asking for photos, which were sent. Now I am not getting any response and stuck with eating oatmeal cookies for a month. Just not good enough and won't be recommending.
Hi Gizzygirl, the reason being is because the bag… Read more
Recent reviews
cookies smaller in size – I purchased these cookies around a year ago and I just recently purchased these again , the one month supply, and when I opened the packet to my disbelief they have gone much smaller in size and not only that, some cookies a larger than others, they are hard as a rock and so sweet, there’s only one word to describe these cookies disappointing! I… Read more
sent a message to the company wanting to know why they are smaller in size and my reply was that they have changed bakers, and when I responded that I would like a refund they ignored my request. I am not happy at all, they are terrible, every hour you have to eat one as you get hungry and they do not satisfy your hunger, waste of time dont even bother, better to eat fruit, more healthier.
Hi Brandon, we’re genuinely sorry to hear about your… Read more
The easiest diet – I started the cookie diet as part of a new year's resolution and have lost over 10kg already. What I love about it is the convenience. I can just grab my bag of cookies in the morning and that's it! There is no need for messy shakes or food prep. I love the additional free app which helps me track my progress. Show details · 1
Amazing – I loosely followed the diet and wow! lost 6kg’s in 4 weeks down to 86kg then plateaued. I’m tall so this is probably close to my ideal weight. I didn’t drink enough water and ate whatever I wanted for dinner and desert. Occasional fried chicken, burgers and pizza along with home cooked meals. I’ve never eaten breakfast regularly and… Read more · 1
continued this so I was only eating 2-4 cookies a day depending how busy I was at work.
I do occasional light physical work so maybe this helped but I’m shocked at how well this diet works. Very convenient hunger busters for my busy days.
When I eventually ran out of my mixed 4 boxes I gained the 6kg back in 2 weeks!
Re-ordered and the weights melting off once more.
Chocolate is the only flavour for me personally, yum.
Expect the consistency of hard cake and you won’t be disappointed.
Beware of Sugar Bombs: Disappointing – I recently decided to try out a new brand of diet cookies that boasted of being low in calories and sugar yet still delicious. Unfortunately, my experience with these sugar-loaded diet cookies was nothing short of disappointing. feeling guilty for falling into the trap of false advertising From the moment I took my first bite, I was overwhelmed by… Read more
an intense sweetness that bordered on sickening. It was clear that these cookies had been packed with an excessive amount of sugar substitutes which resulted in an artificial taste that lingered in my mouth unpleasantly. The supposed absence of sugar was far from evident given the overly sweet flavor that dominated each cookie Texture-wise, these diet cookies fell flat as well. They were dry, crumbly, and lacking any satisfying crunch. Biting into one felt like consuming a bland, lifeless mass that barely resembled a traditional cookie. It's worth noting that they completely lacked the softness and chewiness that one typically associates with a decent cookie Furthermore, their nutritional claims proved to be deceiving. Despite being marketed as diet-friendly.
Hi Tamo, appreciate your point of view, There are… Read more
Very Sugary – I attempted the Cookie Diet, however I found the cookies very sugary. They made me feel quite sick after only a couple days. The theory of eating every 2 hrs can work for other food so instead of wasting your money on sugary cookies just eat healthy snacks instead. Get your metabolism going in a healthier way. Show details
Hi Myss, There are only 4g of sugar per cookie.… Read more
Find out how Cookie Diet compares to other Diet & Weight Loss Programs
Know better, choose better.
Not for ne – I lost a lot of weight previously but being back at work I thought these cookies would be ideal and easy. Nope not at all. No matter how I try I find cookies dull and boring and can’t manage with the taste of them. I’ve tried multiple times with it but no luck as the cookies are so awful I can’t stick to it. Ordered two months supply but am… Read more
throwing them out. Disappointed as they aren’t cheap. Going back to what was working last year instead. Lite n easy and a monthly doctors appointment for a health check in and weight loss check. These cookies also provide No vitamin etc
Hi Kay, this year we are working on developing new… Read more
Don't waste $350 on horrible biscuits – I bought a 2 month supply of mixed biscuits. I did everything it said to do. The biscuits were dry and tasted horrible. I increased my exercise and had one diet meal a day. The cinnamon oatmeal and maple pancakes were disgusting. I did not look forward to eating 7 days of them. I lost no weight and sadly lost $350 on something that did not work. Show details
Hi Andrew S. please reach out to use via email we would love to chat to you about this.
Great Results and great taste – Highly recommended! Unlike most diets, this is very easy to incorporate into your regular daily life. Have been on regularly and progressively seeing results Show details · 1
Amazing, I can eat cookies every day! – I've lost over 20kg since I started the Cookie Diet! I couldn't believe it at first; that cookies can be a regular part of my diet. But I started taking them whenever I had cravings and they would make me feel full and keep my satiety at bay, and overtime I started losing weight. I'm now down to 92kg and I was approximately 115kg when I started … Read more · 2
Totally worth it, I highly recommend them; there's no cooking or preparation needed, just a simple, handy and quick treat that tastes great (My favourite flavour is Maple Pancakes, delicious). Ordering process is easy and they're at my place within a day. Prices are great too
The team are knowledgeable, reliable and efficient, and their customer service is very friendly. Thankyou for helping me achieve my weight goals while still satisfying my sweet tooth!
So easy! They taste great too – My only regret is that I didn’t try these sooner! Best replacement for bad snacks, they taste great and I feel good about replacing sugary snacks with these healthy cookies. Thank you cookie diet ❤️ Show details · 1
Game Changer ! – I am now addicted and have got all my friends hooked. I have never seen a product like this before and it’s a real game changer ! lost 15kg already and counting couldn’t be happier ! Only downside is i’m now addicted ;( Show details · 1
Dry as an old boot! – Awful cookies. May as well but a pkt of rice crackers and eat those instead. Threw them all out. All 5 boxes that cost me a fortune. Ugh! Show details
Hi Heymanchic, if you can email us more info we can… Read more
Check biscuits for MOULD before you eat! – Unfortunately I didn't realise the small white specks in my chocolate cookies were mould until I opened a new packet and there it was a large piece of it so obvious. I felt sick that I had eaten mould. I bought a 3 month supply, have 6 boxes left, with an expiry date of October 2023, kept in a cool dry pantry cupboard at home with all my family's… Read more
other food, which aren't mouldy. Can't trust the remaining product now. No joy from the company once reported either unfortunately, even with the photographic evidence, humpf!
Hi Ella, first off would like to apologise that you… Read more
Extra Information
ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback… Read more