697 reviews
AI reviews summary
Farmers Pick receives praise for its mission to reduce food waste and support local farmers, with many users highlighting the exceptional freshness and flavour of the produce compared to major supermarkets. The service is popular for its "surprise" element, which encourages culinary creativity and increased vegetable consumption. However, significant recurring issues with delivery reliability, missing items, and a perceived decline in quality for long-term subscribers have led to frustration.
Pros
- Product Freshness and Taste: Users frequently report that the fruit and vegetables are "juicy," "crisp," and "earthy," often lasting much longer in the fridge than supermarket alternatives.
- Variety and Culinary Inspiration: The seasonal "lucky dip" nature of the boxes encourages users to try new recipes and diverse produce they wouldn't typically purchase.
- Value for Money: Most users find the quantity of produce provided in the boxes to be generous and more affordable than equivalent organic or premium supermarket ranges.
- Environmental Impact: The plastic-free packaging and the initiative to save "imperfect" produce from landfill resonate strongly with eco-conscious consumers.
Cons
- Delivery and Logistics Failures: Recurring complaints involve boxes being left in the sun, delivered to incorrect addresses, or drivers ignoring specific accessibility and drop-off instructions.
- Missing or Incomplete Orders: There is a significant pattern of missing "add-on" items, such as meat, eggs, or fruit boxes, with some users receiving only half of their paid order.
- Poor Customer Service Accessibility: The lack of a contact phone number and reliance on slow email responses or AI-generated bots is a major point of contention when resolving urgent issues.
- Quality Consistency: While initial boxes are often high quality, some long-term customers report a "steady decline" featuring bruised fruit, rotten potatoes, or "shrinkflation" in box weights.
Verdict
Farmers Pick is an excellent choice for households looking to support local growers and access high-quality, flavourful produce that lasts. However, the service is currently marred by inconsistent delivery partners and a customer support system that many find difficult to navigate when orders go wrong. Prospective users should be prepared to manage their subscription closely and may face challenges if they require precise delivery handling.
Bad delivery letting down good product and great mission. The last two deliveries have been left outside our gate on the footpath. We raised it with FP after the first time together with the fact it was quite clear based on the condition of the produce that it had been "out for delivery" for a while. They comped us $20. This appears to be a new… Read more
delivery partnership. Today was a repeat experience.
Sorry to be cancelling as love the mission but it's not worth the hassle.
Please see the pineapple below. This is a genuine hygiene issue, not a minor quality concern. The fruit is clearly old and in such poor condition that it looks like it has been used as a football in a warehouse. This is well beyond a bruised apple or a dropped watermelon and is completely unacceptable. As a result, I will be cancelling my orders… Read more
going forward, as I no longer have any confidence in the quality control or the people responsible for packaging the food.
I will also be reporting this issue, as customers should not be receiving produce in this condition.
Love the variety and we love the increased diversity of fresh produce we eat. I also enjoy the challenge of using up the remainder, and learning how to make preserves and pickles to reduce waste Show reply
Reviews with attachments
So happy with delivery of small veggie box Plus Josh’s eggs. Fresh and versatile each time and they last longer than supermarket veggies and no plastic packaging! Show reply
Ten months on and we are still very happy with our medium, fortnightly, fruit and vegetables delivery. There is plenty of variety with the quantity of veg exceeding the fruit, which suits us perfectly. I have expanded my recipe repertoires to increase veg consumption eg: turkey and veg cottage pie with creamy mashed potato and parsnips. A dinner… Read more · 1
winner!
On occasion, Farmers Pick have had to change our delivery day due to a public holiday in that week, but they send out an email to let me know and I work around it. There is also the option online for us to skip a delivery or two if we’re away or it’s not convenient to receive a delivery for that week.
I love the convenience and look forward to receiving the delivery. My grandson had fun for the recent delivery, emptying the box, saying colours and learning the names of different fruits and vegetables. It kept him occupied and he enjoyed helping to put the fruit and veg in the fridge. Win!
- +1
Such a great choice each week and very fresh I've made comment on my FB page Show reply
I made pineapple and passion fruit jame Excellent fruit and great suppliers Show reply
Received so many zucchini’s in the box, came in handy at the right time. Prepped the children’s lunches for back to school. Chicken and zucchini meatballs and zucchini slice. Show 2 replies
Ordered the cherries and am very pleased with the quality, delivery and the price Show reply
Love the variety and the quantity, along with the convenience. The perfectly imperfect fruit and vegetable have been perfect Show reply
Lovely and fresh fruit and veggies with all the flavour. The meat has been amazing. It has made me realise how much available food in supermarkets has changed in my lifetime. I’m actually enjoying cooking again because it all tastes so amazing. Cute little quirks in some of the shapes which is fun and doesn’t have any negative effects. Show reply
Absolutely happy with my first box and can’t wait for the next. Customer service is also above and abyeon. Show reply
Find out how Farmers Pick compares to other Food & Drink Shops
Know better, choose better.
We absolutely love our Farmers Pic boxes. It’s like a surprise package that encourages you to make meals you haven’t thought of or made for years. The flavour and freshness of everything received is next level and gives me confidence that I’m taking extra care of my body with fresh produce as opposed to produce sitting in cool rooms for months… Read more · 1
that then go off quickly when you get them home. This does not happen with Farmers Pic and the freshness lasts for days to weeks depending on the veg. I’m never going back to super market fruit and veg again. Keen to try the meats next.
Most of the fruits tasted fresh and great, however, mangoes were too ripe and of waste. They were stored at the bottom of the box which made them squeezed and spoilt. In the second order, arrival time was confusing, kept on delaying. More accurate timing would help. Show reply
Absolutely love my farmers pick box that arrives each week overflowing with quality fruit and vegetables. The medium box has exceeded all expectations! A fantastic variety of seasonal fruit and vegetables. Show reply
Love the products organic choices are great the only thing you can only delete 4 veg from the list to choose from .I would like to delete a few more as I don’t eat all vegetables other than that I would recommend ,every thing is so fresh and tasty ..chicken, fish, beef lamb and veg Show reply
I'm super happy with my products. Thanks so much for your services, it is great to trust in your team, what we eat is very important for us. Show reply
I am super impressed with the quality of the produce. The veggies and fruit are so fresh and delicious. So much better than store bought. The meat Is excellent butcher quality. I have more than halved my food budget and doubled the quantity and quality. Show reply
Latest follow-ups
Received my second box on Saturday afternoon and it was crammed full of beautifully fresh fruit and vegetables. There was so much my vegetable and fruit crisper in my fridge is crammed full. The apples are so juicy I have not had one like that for… Read more · 2
years. I am extremely happy with my order and look forward to the surprise of the different fruits and vegetables to try each fortnight. Thank you :)
Follow-up · I am still purchasing Farmers Pick fruit, vegetables and meat a year later. Have used everything in the box. Fruit and vegetables are always fresh and the meat is second to none for taste. I still love to receive my box of goodies every fortnight and its a highlight for my young grandchildren to open the box and sort through naming all the fruits and vegetables and helping to put in the fridge. Thank you for such an awesome service
The products are very good, but out of 5 orders, only 1 arrived well. On one occasion, they only delivered half of my meat order. On 3 occasions, they left it at the wrong address; I had to go to every building on my street looking for the boxes.… Read more
The last time, my partner had to go looking for them when he got home from the office, in the middle of summer, with the meat out of the refrigerator all day. They compensated us each time, but it's not worth it; it's a lot of work. Very bad service, a real shame.
Follow-up · What was the compensation like? I received a refund for the missing products. How was customer service? Very friendly but not very helpful. The order was supposed to be delivered on Friday, and when I contacted them because it wasn't in my building and couldn't find it, sometimes they didn't reply until Monday... meaning all that food was left out in the open, anywhere. Very sad. How was the packaging? Good, in my opinion
Thanks so much for sharing your honest experience.… Read more
I have received 2 boxes now and both have been such good value. The variety of fruits and vegetables have been excellent. It has been so much fun thinking up new recipes for some veggies that I would not usually purchase. Our meals have been so… Read more · 2
varied and I have frozen so many leftover portions of each meal that we can eat for another 2 weeks without cooking anything new . I have suspended my next weekly box so that I can empty my freezer of all those meals.
Follow-up · I feel that the quality of some fruits and vegetables has fallen off eg dry old celery, small aubergines brown inside, over ripe bruised bananas, woody parsnips, green potatoes. Other things have been good and varied I have always eaten the full range of vegetables so nothing new in the boxes. However, it has been interesting finding new recipes… Read more
Find out how Farmers Pick compares to other Food & Drink Shops
Know better, choose better.
Positive reviews
After a miss hap with a box last week, I contacted farmers pick an i was promptly refunded which was great, today the box i was refunded got delivered with my meat order which I was not expecting as I was refunded an bonus sampler of cheese, thanks guys I truly appreciate it an you have helped me more then you know. Show reply
We were really happy with our first vegie box, and will add fruit to the next order. Mikko was pro-active in resolving a missing item, even before we'd noticed. I love the premise of what Farmers Pick doing in terms of supporting producers and reducing food waste. Execution seems great so far as well, nice one. Show reply
I was still going through my 2 person box which was very generous so for the next one downsized. Again a wonderful selection of fruit and vegetables. I’m a convert. Love my farmers pick !! Show reply
Negative reviews
These guys started great but rapidly lost their standing . Last lot of veggies & many prior became smaller in volume each time , rotten potato in one box not pleasant and hard to understand how it could have got in there. Veggies of poor quality and random things you couldn’t use . Had a lettuce smaller than my hand which wouldn’t even be a salad… Read more
for two people , threw out a full bag of Brussel sprouts that were so tough you couldn’t cut through stems easily ! Price increased without my consent after a month or so of subscription making it expensive . If the quality was there would have persevered but become well below supermarket standards … wow ! No contact no Phone number so Emailed and had no response this time , a refund would be least of fixing the issue . This was my second subscription stopped previously as orders for meat when weighed were under weight by 100gms or more . Very disappointed and would not recommend anymore .
Hey there, we're genuinely sorry to read this and… Read more
I ordered a $190 worth of goods on Thursday meat veggies fruit meat. Then on Friday I get a confirmation for $142 dollars less the fruit and pantry items and they charged me over $13 dollars for the delivery. I sent them an email they said one order was ordered Thursday and a smaller order was placed Friday (no they direct debited it as a… Read more
subscription) when the first box was already ordered. they refunded the 142 took 3 days to get my money back. Then I said the invoice was missing dog treats fruit pack etc and I had been charged freight after placing a large order. they refunded the fruit pack and not the delivery. My order arrives didn't even knock no meat or milk I purchased around one hundred dollars of refrigerated goods that were not delivered. You can't call them they emailed saying they would look into it. If I get a refund then I am going to have to wait to get the money back and try and go shopping. First and last order do not deal with them. My fruit was squashed and split. I though I was giving Aussie farmers a help out. It is too expensive and too many headaches to deal with them I would have given them less stars if I could. No invoice issued.
Hey there, we're truly sorry to hear about your… Read more
Whilst I'm keen to support farmers and turn away from companies like Coles and Woolworths, what turned me off of this service was the subscriptions. Why cant I be in control of when and what I order in my own time during a cost of living crisis? People live busy schedules and are watching their budgets more than ever which companies like this… Read more
don't seem to consider, whilst their produce might be cheaper their focus is still on revenue, same as Coles and Woolworths. If you're not on top of managing your subscriptions you'll find you'll be spending more money, unnecessarily.
Hey there! Thanks for taking the time to share your… Read more
Recent reviews
Had high hopes and used this service as a means of accessing fresh produce and was really disappointed. The lack of communication, payment for items that were never received and delivery drivers that just simply didn't seem to care about customers receiving orders intact and complete was enough to look around at alternatives
Hey TJSara! We’re really sorry to hear this was your… Read more
I used to be a big fan of Farmers Pick, but I have had cause to complain about the quality of various items included in my box for each of my last 4 deliveries (eg butternut pumpkin rotten all down one side, moldy tomatoes, inedible rotting peaches. In a strategy designed to keep customers, they offer a refund as $ off next delivery, but I would… Read more
rather have good quality in the first place. I am also finding that the varieties included have narrowed and the nice surprises of unusual vegies or fruit are fewer and further between. I have just received an email increasing the price (fair enough given the petrol situation) but more annoyingly reducing the weight of the box by 10%. Shrinkflation does not provide good value for customers... and I am betting that we would still receive boxes heavy on cheaper foods -- carrots and yet more sweet potatoes.
Hey there, We’re really sorry to hear about your… Read more (+1 reply)
ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.
We're so sorry to hear your experience ended this… Read more