Review your last buy on ProductReview.com.au
23 reviews
  • Thumbnail
Leana C.
Leana C.
 

What did you do to smarties…. Omg yuk. Got them for the first time in years, spat them out immediately. They’re disgusting! Faded in colour and absolutely inedible.

Nestle
Nestle    

Hi Leana, We’re sorry to hear of the frustration you’ve… Read more

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
Amanda Austin
Amanda Austin
 

It turns out that Smarties really are Pants! – Just had a tube of smarties for the first time in years… what the heck have you done!!!!! They were bland and the shell is no longer a shell but a coloured coating!!! Never again! Lost a customer. Stopped buying from Cadburys too as they have completely lost it and are on a low quality high profit mission. We just want the chocolate to be how it was back in the 70’s! I don’t expect you to listen! Show details

Nestle
Nestle    

Hi Amanda, we hate that you’ve had this experience but… Read more

Disillusioned
Disillusioned2 posts
 

Blatant Ripoff in Bulk Packets – Bought the multi smarties pack (tiny boxes) and over the course of 2 weeks, we had 2 x empty boxes and many that were half to a third full. This is obviously a cost saving activity, which is disgraceful. Nestle...any comments that may negate my grievance ?? Last time for Nestle, absolute b.s.. Show details

Nestle
Nestle    

We are sorry to hear about your experience, we’d like to… Read more

Brad S.
Brad S.NSW4 posts
 

Very poor compared to 20 years ago, do not buy – This product is not what it used to be; very little chocolate, ... all sugar. This was always a top quality product compared to USA candy/chocolate "bars". It is now, much worse. Why is the company killing its brand like this? Now we really need to focus on European chocolate based products. Show details

Brad S.
Brad S.   

I just resd the other reviews. This company has lost their "direction" on this product. Milking… Read more (+3 replies)

Aussie T.
Aussie T.
 

Just yukky taste – Bought Smarties for the first time in ages to decorate my granddaughters Birthday cake and the taste of them is not good. The outer shell colours look like they are faded and the chocolate tastes like its a plant based cheap chocolate. They actually tasted like they were a bit rancid. They were not out of date and purchased from Woolworths. Sorry… Read more

Nestle but your smarties have gone the same way as Milo, cheap and yuk tasting and nothing like the original that we have been bought up with.

Nestle
Nestle    

We are sorry to hear about your experience with our… Read more

genesis895
genesis8952 posts
 

Not so Smarties – Just like Lucuzade, another once great product, ruined by some idiot. Smarties today taste of pure sugar and cheap Easter Egg Chocolate, the crap you get in a cheap party bag. Well done Show details

Kym
Kym4 posts
 

Taste less – One thing I have noticed is the change in taste, almost like cheap chocolate. I grew up loving smarties, the flavour of the chocolate was nice, like a good Easter egg, but now, so disappointing that children grow up thinking that is how they should taste. It would be wonderful if you could rethink and look at your receipe , are you trying to save on an ingredient. Make them great again. Show details

Nestle
Nestle    

Hi Kym, we're sorry to hear you're no enjoying our… Read more

Amanda T
Amanda T9 posts
 

Dreadful! – Take note of yours reviews. Your taste is absolute rubbish! You have clearly changed the mixture somehow. Bought a smarties egg that was $20! What a waste of money. Was thrown in the bin. Tasted dreadful and how outrageous to ask $20 for a medium sized egg that tastes so horrible. A zero star is more like it. Smarties used to taste amazing, now like everything else, the greedy companies charge ridiculous amounts and the quality is crap.

Nestle
Nestle    

Oh dear. That doesn't sound right Amanda. We're sorry to… Read more

Jennifer Jean Reese
Jennifer Jean Reese
 

thick chalk wall – the hard chalk coating not only tastes terrible, its so thick u barely get any chocolate. the hard coating cuts my gums if i try and eat them fast Show details

Nestle
Nestle    

Hi Jennifer, we're really sorry to hear of your experience… Read more

Jennifer D.
Jennifer D.
 

I normally love smarties… – I bought a package of smarties today and upon eat two rolls I noticed a smell that resembled cleaner. And the taste was pungent, leaving an unpleasant taste in your mouth. Show details

Nestle
Nestle    

Hi Jennifer, oh dear that doesn't sound right. It sounds… Read more

Polly
Polly
 

Taste and smell of detergent/washing up liquid – Bought two tubes of smarties last week and they were delicious as ever. Bought two this week and they had an awful taste and smell of detergent. Couldn’t eat them at all. Show details

Nestle
Nestle    

We're really sorry to hear about your unpleasant… Read more

Fox
Fox
  Fair Incentive

No more smarties – We always buy smarties for our children as we grew up with it. Until I recently tasted the smarties of today! Just awful! I wont be giving my children smarties again. Everywhere I go I ask adults to taste smarties before giving it to their children. All agree smarties is no longer as nice as it used to be.

Nestle
Nestle    

Hi there, we are sorry to hear about your experience with… Read more

Becks
Becks
 

Musty cardboard taste – Always loved smarties. Bought a pack yesterday . All I could taste was musty cardboard. I asked my husband to try them hoping it was just me. Unfortunately not. I am totally on board with making the packets greener & using recycling. it's really compromised the taste. won't be buying again. Show details

Nestle
Nestle    

Hi Becks, oh dear that doesn't sound right. Thanks for… Read more

Chocolates

Find out how Nestle Smarties compares to other Chocolates

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
Melissa H.
Melissa H.
 

Best chocolate ever – Best chocolate ever it is so yum and addictive I could eat thousands every day and night . Perfectly balanced and delicious yum yum yum! Blue red fellow great. Colours yeh yeh

Smarties lover - or was
Smarties lover - or was
 

Rank and awful - smarties used to be so good and now sooooooo bad – Brought up in york and on smarties …just bought a bag and they are now vile! They are tasteless and cardboardy and the used to be so good - why would you make a brilliant product so much worse. Last pack we will ever buy !!!!

Nestle
Nestle    

We are sorry to hear about your experience with our… Read more

Louby L.
Louby L.
 

Smarties taste awful – Smarties used to be a delightful chocolate treat. This is no longer the case, the thick case is horrible compared to the sharp crunch and lighter texture of the old Smarties. The centre is overly sweet and doesn't taste like real chocolate anymore. I also miss the orange smartie that tasted of orange. The new Smarties are horrible, please bring back the old recipe. Show details

Nestle
Nestle    

Hi Louby, we're sorry to hear you haven't enjoyed your… Read more

Jacqueline S.
Jacqueline S.
 

nestle ruined smarties – Nestle took out Cadbury Chocolate in Smarties and introduced Nestle Chocolate, now they taste like M and M:s Put REAL chocolate back in Smarties!!!! Show details

Jill
Jill5 posts
 

What happened? – I used to love Smarties. Haven't tasted one for years until I bought some to decorate a children's birthday cake. What has happened? They are no longer plump and juicy. The small amount of chocolate in them tastes powdery, like the cheapest Easter eggs. The colours are dead and the shells lack crispness. Never again! Just another memory.

erica245
erica2452 posts
 

colours of smarties – There is something wrong with the smarties. What is it you say? It is the colours there are too many of one colour I think that there should be the exact same amount of the colours in every packet or box otherwise it is ot fair because some people don't like all the colours that have the most and that just ruins it. So in my opinon there should be the exact colours. i liked all the yummy colours and the outside there was too many of one colour

Sada
SadaVIC747 posts
 

Bad – I dont really buy these often at all because I am not a big fan of the taste. The great point for these is ofcourse that they dont have any artificial colours or flavours, considering they are so colourful! Overall, I dont like the taste and dont mind eating them if someone offered them to me, but I wouldnt buy them when I want a chocolate treat.… Read more

The great thing about these is that they dont have any artificial colours or flavours, which is a big bonus. They dont taste as good as M & M's, and I think its because they arent as crunchy, crispy and chocolately as M & M's are.

craftymumma
craftymumma70 posts
 

OK – By far, I prefer M'n'Ms to Smarties. The taste of Smarties comes nowhere near to M'n'Ms. The colours are better though and that makes Smarties great for baking, as I stated. Kids love them, but not so much adults. Smarties are a pretty fun treat for kids and great for decorating baking, such as biscuits, cakes and other goodies. If you don't want… Read more

your kids to eat too much chocolate, you can give them just a few. I used these for potty training! I don't think the taste is that great and am often left feeling disappointed after eating Smarties.

lauraj12
lauraj12TAS18 posts
 

Good – Finally, one more product kids can enjoy without mum having the guilts of articial colourings & having to read the packet over&over. Kids love them, especially the little funsize boxes as a treat & they are the perfect size to treat your kids and not have to deprive them the rest of a bigger packet. Still great colours and still perfect for… Read more

buttons on your gingerbread men. Must have in the cupboard! The fact they no longer use artifical colourings. Hooray! Nothing really stands out. Maybe as an adult heaps of better tasting alternatives, but smarties will always have their place.

sarahjo
sarahjo70 posts
 

Bad – Smarties used to be one of my favourite treats as a child. I loved the crisp outside shell and the yummy chocolate centre however I feel that they have either changed the recipe or my tastes have matured over time. The last time I had smarties I didn't enjoy them at all. They seemed really tasteless. They were still crispy as I remembered but the… Read more

chocolate inside was not the same quality that I remembered. It was almost too sugary and gritty. Maybe they still appeal to children, after all I guess that's the target audience anyway. For me, I was sadly disappointed. A fun pack of colourful chocolates that appeal to children. Come in a variety of box sizes. Not as good as they used to be.

Mezari
Mezari   

To Sarahjo - I believe when they changed from artificial colouring to natural colouring, the… Read more

ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.