Review your last buy on ProductReview.com.au
2The Motley Fool

The Motley Fool

 Verified
2The Motley Fool
1.6

552 reviews

Positive vs Negative
15%5%80%
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • See allThumbnail
Transparency ?
1.8
Rates and Fees
1.7
552 reviews
1  d7516787  · Surprised they are still in business based on their reviews.
1  Sudip C.  · Worst recommendation.. The company which is going down every day they ask for buy more and make people in big financial trouble like TWE. They are
1  Walter  · Absolutely terrible info that they sell. No real good insight. Just click bait. Do not recommend.
1  Corinneb1  · Posts inaccurate AI generated content that has caused share holder misinformation. See WBT annoucement that a false article published on this site.
1  Kerry M.  · Took money $299.00 for a subscription I never signed up for
1  geoff s.  · horriffic. I subscribed to extreme opportinities as they suggested across 20 shares and lost 81% in 4 years. Only 2 of these 20 went up
Huntsman
Huntsman QLD 57 posts
 

I have been with these 'Fools' for about a year and am amazed at how poor their recommendations are. I have lost thousands thanks to them. There non stop advertising for upgrades and special deals is not great either. I would of been better off just buying a good ETF like VGS or NDQ.

Ask the reviewer
CXP
CXP
 

It’s nothing more than an upsell scam. Buy a subscription and you’ll get a couple of emails a day enticing you to pay for yet another subscription with the promise this new one will reveal the real truth.

Ask the reviewer
  • Thumbnail
Joseph
Joseph NSW 8 posts
   Verified

Be extremely careful giving Motley Fool Australia your credit card details. They use classic "dark pattern" tactics to trap you into auto-renewals. I decided I didn't want to renew my subscription, so I logged into my account to cancel. I spent over 15 minutes clicking through every single bloody menu and account setting looking for a simple… Read more

"Cancel Membership" button. It doesn't exist. They make it incredibly easy to sign up online with a few clicks, but deliberately remove any online cancellation option, forcing you to email or call them to beg to be let go.

This is a highly unethical business practice designed purely to create friction so people give up and get charged again.

I had to resort to sending a formal legal demand citing Australian Consumer Law and ACCC guidelines on misleading conduct just to force them to stop my auto-renewal. I have also paid for my current term upfront, which is valid until June 23, 2026. I have had to explicitly warn them in writing not to illegally cut off my access early just because I refused their auto-renewal trap.

If a digital financial company cannot provide a transparent digital exit button in 2026, they do not deserve your business. Completely dodgy and unethical.

Reviews with attachments

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
Conrad B
Conrad B NSW 6 posts
   Verified

I subscribed to Motley Fool in good faith due to their well known name, even though I was doing well picking my own buys, using info from other sources. After I subscribed, they started sending me deals to get a higher levels of subscriptions. If there are at least 2 higher levels of subscriptions, what am I getting? I'm getting the left overs.… Read more

I know investing is for the long term, but in this bullish market, their tips are falling, where mine are doing great. If I'm getting Bronze level service, I should have been told when I paid.

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +1Thumbnail
Beany
Beany QLD 5 posts
 Published  · Edited   Verified

Scam site. You think you have joined as a member with all the benefits, but they hold information back and charge you for add ons. The recommendations are not great either. I work in the same industry as one and they fail to identify the risks. AVOID…the non inclusions of their best advice just keep coming (see photos)

  • Thumbnail
Nabil
Nabil NSW
 

Deceptive bad advice – I find The Motley Fool to be clickbait that often leads to potentially poor investment advice. Recently, they promoted a company boasting a dividend yield of 9.6%. This recommendation contradicts the typical advice of caution towards companies offering high dividends, especially considering this company's historical average dividend of around 1%.… Read more

This discrepancy raises concerns about the reliability of The Motley Fool's guidance, as it appears to deviate from standard investment principles.

  • Thumbnail
Stefan
Stefan WA 15 posts
   Verified

Don't use it, A subscription opens you up to much more SPAM – The base subscription that's meant to help you with investing purely opens you up to SPAM and Motley Fool pedling more opportunities if you pay for more subscriptions and given the track record of poor recommendations I'm very reluctant to take the gamble Show details

Latest follow-ups

bob c.
bob c.
 

Motley is a Scam – stocks go up and down, but only stock I bought that disappeared was one Motley Fool recommended

 Follow-up  · Bike - cannondale best cycle maker, who went bust when CEO decided to compete with honda and yamaha. motley didnt warn us

Positive reviews

tushar k.
tushar k. NSW
   Verified

Worth the cost – Hate it's auto renewal policy which can't be cancelled from website itself after member login. But they cancelled it pretty promptly after I called the customer care. The suggestion on stocks are worth the cost.

Jayton
Jayton QLD 2 posts
 

GOod system- I like their long term attitude and good source of information – I use it to gather information as I don't have time to my own detailed advice. Like their logic behind their recommendations. They do send out a lot of spam which I chose to ignore

Tamara C.
Tamara C. QLD 2 posts
 

Great service, very helpful – Motley Fool offers great subscription services which have greatly assisted me in my investing. When I wanted to take a break, it was easy to cancel and the team were very understanding and helpful. Excellent product for a very reasonable price.

Negative reviews

Rebecca
Rebecca QLD 3 posts
   Verified

As a new-ish investor I signed up to learn more. I am getting upsell sales push emails numerous times every day. The recommended 'picks' have been pretty much the same each time, maybe 1 might change but then they add it back in the following time. Emails come from different people within the organisation so hard to track how many emails. It is 11.50am on Wednesday and I've received 7 'upsell' emails since Monday. I DO NOT recommend.

Find out how The Motley Fool compares to other Forex & Share Trading Platforms

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
darchand
darchand NSW 5 posts
 

Geeze disappointing to see all the bad reviews. I was a member for a few years which ended around 7 years ago, and they had some very good tips. All Aussie stocks. You need to be a bit selective and go with stocks in industries you know well - I went with some of their tech stocks and did pretty well. Wish I'd hung on to some a lot longer, eg… Read more

Nearmap and Xero - they went up a lot after I got out. I suggest you sit on their recommendations for a few months, as you will prob get a better entry, or avoid a costly mistake. Research the management, read the fin reports, do your own due diligence. Sell when you think it's over valued. If you want to mindlessly follow stock tips, you won't make money anywhere. Also, don't exclusively trade their tips - follow the market & make your own selections as well. Treat it as an extra source of info, and you won't get (as) burnt.

Peter
Peter NSW 8 posts
 Published  · Edited

Absolute SCAM. as others said I paid the subscription then found their recommended buys ALL became losses. I have lost thousands and then they keep sending you upgrades to a higher recommended service After many emails about their advice they canceled the And they have auto renew subscription.

Recent reviews

Flora E.
Flora E.
 

From my initial interaction with Laura Cooper’s team, I experienced a high level of professionalism, empathy, and responsiveness. They took the time to fully understand my concerns, offering prompt and well-structured guidance throughout the entire process. What truly set them apart was their commitment to providing customized, effective… Read more

solutions—not just temporary fixes. Their expertise, patience, and consistent support turned a stressful situation into one of clarity and trust. I highly recommend Laura Cooper for anyone seeking reliable and professional assistance.

Resoxit.cc

Just My Opinion
Just My Opinion VIC 7 posts
 Published  · Edited   Verified

I certainly was a fool. They got me and I stupidly fell for the first upgrade to 'Silver' from 'Share Advisor' on sign up not twigging this would become the norm. Once you have joined you then start to get offered higher levels to subscribe to. Knowing this at the start I would never have joined as had an expectation I would be getting their… Read more

best information. I expected to get this access and not to need to continually subscribe to higher levels. Safe to say after failing to get a refund (outside of 30 days) I have cancelled my auto renewal, waste of money for me. Scroll down read the numerous similar review, wish I had.

Michelle
Michelle 3 posts
 

Save your money. I signed up & paid an annual subscription to understand investing in the Australian share market. I received no advice on how the share market worked but lots of - invest in these stocks now. Because I was new to this, I trusted the motley fool australia and put money on 2 of the 5 companies they recommended. The shares were… Read more

already bearish & have since tanked and I'm unable to sell them because I've lost 49% & 34% respectively. Going back over the original advice, I realised the advice was months old by the time I received it and the market had changed. I only wish they had held off telling me which shares to invest in rather given me given me clear advice on what to look for, how to interpret the research from stock brokers & to do my own research on each company. Maybe they did ? but the amount of emails advising me to buy, marketing for their new products etc was so overwhelming that I couldn't keep up and just went with what I thought was good recommendations from a reputable advisory firm. Needless to say, I won't be renewing. I get better advice from Google.

Shannon Roberts
Shannon Roberts 8 posts
 Published  · Edited

Criminals, thieves, crooks. I found out about Motley about 3 years ago. Can't recall what interaction I had with them and haven't gone to the website since. Think I get an email everynow and then. All of a sudden $300 came out of my credit card on Saturday. No email or notification. Absolute thieves!! I've written to them on every email i could find because their phone number is disconnected of course. No reply. The guys are criminals.

Mark
Mark WA 2 posts
 

It is so disappointing being a subscriber of Motley Fool. I really have been made a fool: having paid a large annual fee that I was persuaded to bump up to access extra benefits, then to daily get no real investor information at all but endless promotions to subscribe to further services/subscriptions for half price at some exorbitant fee expiring… Read more

in a few hours then extended, almost every day. As a subscriber I get some vague, information-less hook-in trying to get me to buy a further subscriptions to access some promised jewels. You are clearly a self-serving money making con. Scott Phillip’s opinionated drivel just adds insult to injury.

SomeDudeWhoIsUsuallyNice
SomeDudeWhoIsUsuallyNice 27 posts
 

They don’t really offer anything more than what you get through free media. I dont appreciate receiving click bait emails. If you join this you will be treated as a fool and ignorant investor. Will not be renewing

Rommel
Rommel NSW 2 posts
 

Is zero stars possible? The worse investment decision of my life. The Motley Fool recommendations are terrible. They were going around telling people banks were a bad investment after COVID, and recommended small technology companies that performed very poorly, some lost 95% of their value. Banks have done very well, wrong as usual. Stay away from these fools.

Find out how The Motley Fool compares to other Forex & Share Trading Platforms

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
John H.
John H. 7 posts
 

Terrible advice and they seem to be trying to artificially inflate shares as well, recommending shares that tanks a few months later (probably after they have sold off all their interests).

James
James 5 posts
 

The bad picks are as numerous as the good picks. In one case, the company listed as a buy went into liquidation a few weeks later, indicating a severe lack of due diligence.

gregorybbennett
gregorybbennett NSW
 

MFs Failed to cancel my subscription 12 months ago. I have had to cancel my credit card to stop the deductions.

Mike C
Mike C VIC 8 posts
 

Don't be a fool by subscribing to Motley Fool! – I got suckered into paying USD $99 annual subscription for a promise of some great advice on investing in stock, etc. etc. Instead, the so-called "advice" was only centered on AI, and only AI. Even worse, the so-called advice I've seen had been predominantly marketing hype to entice you to pay for another USD $300+ for "Epic" subscription. But… Read more

wait... There's more! I went to their FAQ on how to turn off the automatic subscription. The link they provided only took me to the settings page where there was NO way to turn off the automatic renewal!! I think I'm going to have to change my credit card number again by telling the bank that I lost my card.

DAVID
DAVID NSW 8 posts
 

Fraudulent service stay away – Horrible fraudulent service very bad stock advice and bill your credit card without any notification stay away

djb
djb NSW
 

You would do well to avoid Motley Fool recommended buys - at all costs – another very bad Motley Fool recommendation IPG - crashed 22% in one week while the ASX hit record highs. Here’s some smart advice for stocks punters - subscribe to Motley Fool and avoid all their recommendations. That way you wont buy poorly researched un-insightful recommendations.

Sis
Sis VIC 2 posts
 

Be aware – I signed up for The Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor service in 2021 but stopped using it after that year. I was unaware that the subscription would automatically renew every year, as I didn’t notice the reminders they claim to have sent. Unfortunately, I only realized last week that they had been charging me annually without my knowledge. When I… Read more

requested refunds for the years I didn’t use the service, they refused to refund the charges from 2022 and 2023, citing their Terms and Conditions. I was disappointed by their lack of flexibility or understanding of the situation, especially since I hadn’t used the service after 2021.

If you’re considering signing up, be very cautious about their auto-renewal policy and keep an eye on your account statements. This experience has left me feeling frustrated, and I hope others avoid similar issues.

Daniel R
Daniel R
 

One of the worse mistakes I have ever made – I have followed their recommendations, diversified, stayed for the long run. Years later from over 30 stock pics - 27 are losing with many suffering drastic, non recoverable losses such as 90 and 95 percent down. The market has recovered during that time but somewhat not their recommended stocks. This is very odd as you would think that even a… Read more

random stock pick would result in a better outcome. Highly suspicious, featuring and a major concern as I have moved the family savings to their recommendations. We will never be able to recover from this mistake. I have even emailed them the list of pics and outcome years later and asked for an opinion and reevaluation. Yet no one bothered to reply. Stay away!

ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.