Review your last buy on ProductReview.com.au
Budget Direct Gold Comprehensive Car Insurance

Budget Direct Gold Comprehensive Car Insurance

 Verifiedbudgetdirect.com.au
Budget Direct Gold Comprehensive Car Insurance
3.1

465 reviews

Positive vs Negative
57%43%
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • See allThumbnail
Claim Resolution Time
  • <1 week
  •  · 
  • 1-2 weeks
  •  · 
  • 3-4 weeks
  •  · 
  • 1-2 months
  •  · 
  • 3+ months
Claim ApprovedYes · No
Value for Money
3.3
Customer Service
3.2
Timeliness
3.1
Job Satisfaction ?
2.9
Transparency ?
3.0
3 Shaun  · Currently have two policies, my car for three + years, daughters recently. My policy increased more than inflation. Where’s the love ?
5 billy m.  · Amazing price for what I have covered compared to other insurance companies. Very good service as well
5 Bruce W  · Great offer and coverage for fair price. Easy to finalise the policy purchase
5 Dylan  · Quick and easy to setup being my first full comprehensive insurer
5 Anne M  · The representative made getting new insurance easy and spent alot of time comparing different coverage for me.
5 Stephen  · Great cover at a affordable price I highly recommend them
Lupita
Lupita4 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

I WAS UNABLE TO SUBMIT MY CLAIM EVEN AFTER 6 ATTEMPTS. Absolute nightmare. Run away from it, as fast as you can. I tried to submit claim for a no-fault accident. I tried twice online, and 4 times through their call centre. It took 30mins each time, but the submissions didn't go through. Apparently they raised IT ticket, and told me they'll call… Read more

back. I heard nothing. When I called to check on it, they said they don't have any history of any past submission or IT ticket whatsoever. So, I was asked to raise the claim request AGAIN. It took 1 hr, and STILL DIDN'T GET SUBMITTED.

All the Customer care reps were absolute nightmares with 0 empathy. So, it's been 6 days since the accident and the claim is still NOT SUBMITTED. So decide for yourself- is it worth the cheap premium?

Jen P
Jen PVIC10 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

I lodged a claim and paid the excess in December and 6 weeks later am still waiting to be reimbursed for repair costs I paid upfront. I sent copies of the invoices I paid, but then was asked to take my car in to be inspected. I booked the inspection, sent photos of the car, then received a call saying the inspection was not required, but further… Read more

evidence of paid invoices was required. So I cancelled the booking for the inspection and immediately sent through the additional requested evidence. That was sent almost 3 weeks ago now and I’m still waiting to be reimbursed (the amount is less than $300!!!!). Poor communication, very disorganised - I don’t know what’s happened with Budget Direct but I have previously lodged claims under my Home and Car insurance policies (prior to 2020) and never had any issues. This experience has been frustrating and I am eagerly waiting for this claim to be resolved so I can switch to a different insurer.

Jen P
Jen P   

I will be lodging a complaint with AFCA if this isn’t resolved in a reasonable timeframe

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
Arash M.
Arash M.NSW2 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

I have not purchased this insurance and will not. for benefit of public, people please be aware of the fradulent scam Budget Direct is running. attached are two screenshots, first of their Gold PDS part B and second of their website. you can clearly see that they are fradulantly lying on the quote generation of their website about the 21 days… Read more

Accident Car Hire while their PDS is stating 14 days car hire. I'm fairly certain this is illigal. I recommend you to stay clear of this company

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Hi Arash. Thank you for taking the time to provide… Read more

Reviews with attachments

  • Thumbnail
Jason
JasonVictoria
  Verified Gold Comprehensive

Quick and easy phone call The agent was polite helpful and very good at their job. 10 out of 10 This is my third policy so Budget Direct must be doing something right. Show details ·  1

  • Thumbnail
Rey
ReyVIC
  Fair Incentive Gold Comprehensive

Very professional, friendly and all query i need have been answered. Show details ·  1

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +2Thumbnail
Hamish S.
Hamish S.VIC
  Gold Comprehensive

Fast, simple, easy & efficient! – They are fast, simple and efficient! They don’t hound me with never ending email chains. Show details ·  1

  • Thumbnail
Andrew
AndrewSA6 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

Easy with Budget – I had used Budget Direct for insurance on my other car for the last 4 years and so far I've been very happy. And to be honest compared to other insurers for this vehicle Budget Direct were cheaper and It was easy to set up. Show details ·  1

  • Thumbnail
Peter.
Peter.NSW2 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

Pretty good – A good and easy process and a reasonable product, with good add ons Show details ·  1

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
Bec A.
Bec A.South Australia2 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

Reality Behind the Promises Budget Direct advertises that you can “count on Budget,” but my experience has been the exact opposite. After a no-fault accident in September 2024, my comprehensive car insurance claim has become a case study in delay tactics, poor communication, and disregard for customer rights. Endless Delays & Stalling: My claim… Read more

has dragged on for ten months, with the Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR) team repeatedly stalling and failing to provide clear updates.

Secret Vehicle Relocation: My car was moved without my knowledge, and its location was withheld for four months—making it impossible to get an independent assessment. It has been stored in a salvage yard and transported by forklift, causing further deterioration.

Inflated Repair Costs: The assigned repairer took four weeks to produce a grossly inflated quote, listing only OEM parts. When I provided a detailed price comparison showing parts could be sourced for 50% less, Budget Direct dismissed my evidence because I’m “not a panel beater.”

Refusal of Second Opinion: All requests for an independent assessment were denied. I was blocked from accessing my own vehicle and told it belonged to them.

Unjustified Write-Off: The combination of inflated repair costs and undervaluing my rare edition led to my car being written off unnecessarily, contradicting Budget Direct’s own claims about “extending vehicle life.”

Low-Ball Settlement Offer: Only this week did Budget Direct increase the Pre-Accident Market Value (PAMV) to match their independent valuation recorded on file back in November 2024, after months of maintaining a lower figure.

Hire Car Cancelled Without Notice: My hire car entitlement was cancelled in March with no warning, communication, or settlement—breaching their Product Disclosure Statement (PDS)—and while the matter is still with AFCA.

Dismissed Evidence & Poor Communication: My detailed submissions and supporting documents have been ignored or dismissed, and communication has been consistently slow and unhelpful.

Stakeholder Prioritisation Over Customers: When questioned, the IDR team justified their actions by citing “obligations to stakeholders”—not to paying customers.

If you value transparency, fairness, and your rights as a customer, think twice before choosing Budget Direct. My experience shows a company more interested in protecting its bottom line than delivering on its promises or treating customers with respect.

I hope this review helps others make an informed decision and prompts Budget Direct’s management to finally address these ongoing issues

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Hi Bec, We sincerely apologise for any… Read more

  • Thumbnail
Carmen B.
Carmen B.QLD
  Gold Comprehensive

I have been with Budget Direct for nearly 3yrs and recently made my first claim after I was involved in a collision with another vehicle where I was not at fault. My vehicle needed to be towed, it took 3 calls just to organise that, and as it late in the day, I was told I would need to call back in the morning to organise a rental car. I have… Read more

always added this extra to my policy to ensure I would never be left without a vehicle as I travel a reasonable distance to and from work. The next day I had to catch an Uber at my own expense to pick up the rental car which wasn’t available till 11am and I was meant to start work at 8am. Approximately a week later, I received a call to advise me my vehicle had been deemed a write off. The ‘market valve’ amount I would receive to replace the vehicle, was not enough to buy anything comparable! I was also then told I had 2 business days to return the rental car. Today is day 2, I have looked at a few cars, test drove 2, and even made an offer which unfortunately fell short. I called Budget Direct this morning to ask for an extension on the hire car as not only had I not found another option but the pay out was still not in my a/c even if I had. I explained to them how unreasonable it was to take my rental car before my pay out has even hit my bank a/c. How am I now supposed to get to work Budget Direct? How am I meant to get around to view potential replacement cars Budget Direct? When I do purchase my new car you will definitely not be my insurer!

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Hello Carmen. We sincerely apologise for any… Read more

  • Thumbnail
Kalle A.
Kalle A.
  Gold Comprehensive

An old lady reversed into my parked car and scratched the bumper. Budget Direct asked me to send photos of the damage, that’s fair. Then they asked me to show the car to the repairer. Had to take half a day off work to get that sorted. Annoying but OK. Now they are asking me to drive it to a third party independent assessor to show it to them.… Read more

Another half a day off work, which is very difficult to arrange. Called them up and complained; their response - tough, that’s our process. Last time I take my insurance business to them.

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Good morning. Thank you for taking the time to… Read more

Latest follow-ups

Andrew Gilmour
Andrew GilmourVictoria2 posts
  Verified Gold Comprehensive

I am very disappointed with Budget Direct. My son is a leaner driver and is on a policy with my wife and I who are rating 1 drivers. We pay a larger premium for him to be on our policy. He had a very minor accident while under my supervision. We… Read more

reported it to budget direct to make them aware but did not follow through with a claim as the damage was very minor and we could cover it. When the policy came up for renewal they refused to renew because they deemed him a high risk. Remember we did not make a claim. He is no higher risk than another other learner driver. This is a very greedy organisation that desert young Australians while learning to drive. They take our higher premiums but then when they think there is a minor risk of delving into their pockets they opt out. Un-Australian and very greedy and disappointing.

I raised an official complaint with Budget Direct but it fell on deaf ears. They will not allow us to renew our insurance because of a younger learner driver having a minor accident in the last twelves with no claim. They are not interested in supporting customers just lining their pockets with policies with minimal risk of claims.

 Follow-up  · After escalating the complaint Budget Direct overturned their decision and have now offered insurance for my son under the existing terms an a higher premium. Which I am Ok with.

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Good morning Andrew. Thankyou for providing this… Read more (+2 replies)

Car Insurance

Find out how Budget Direct Gold Comprehensive Car Insurance compares to other Car Insurance

Know better, choose better.

Compare all

Positive reviews

Trevor J.
Trevor J.2 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

After buying a car, I called 1300 306 560 to find out how to transfer and upgrade my existing Budget Direct policy to the new vehicle. Rebecca had it sorted out in no time. Friendly and super well-organised she had the right cover for me and everthing set up for a smooth transition. Impressive! Show details ·  1

Karku
Karku5 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

The policy was easy to purchase although it wouldn't let me change the start date. I had to ring to change it, the customer service representative was most helpful and friendly, he quickly rectified the problem. The policy is very competitive and good value. Show details ·  1

Arish
ArishACT2 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

Got a excellent deal including hire car for comprensive insurance the next day got a call from their representative for a much better deal. Loved the service and had a slight problem and called thier support team and problem got resolved in 2 mins thanks to ntokozo. Overall, lovely experience from Budget Direct. Will keep updating in the future Show details ·  1

Negative reviews

lucy d.
lucy d.VIC2 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

If you hold a policy with Budget Direct, be prepared for persistent and excessive contact during the claims process. You may receive repeated messages over an extended period, while practical progress remains limited. Car rental arrangements can be prolonged week after week, yet there appears to be little meaningful action or clear commitment. Additionally, the policy is not inexpensive, making the overall experience particularly disappointing. Show details

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Hello Lucy. I sincerely apologise for any… Read more (+1 reply)

Petra
PetraVIC8 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

Had already completed via website but rang with a question and had to go over EVERYTHING again which was unnecessary and total waste of time. Lots of background noise made it difficult to hear at times. Otherwise all good Show details

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Hi Petra, thankyou for taking time to leave… Read more (+1 reply)

Danny
DannySA24 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

Don't be fooled by its word, it's not budget at all, they will mess you around as much as possible so you'll just give up the fight and.cave in. I was hit while I was not in the car, hit n run. I reported to police same day and to insurance, someone called in to say they hit the car, great I received name and car registration from police, not… Read more

good enough for budget wanted her adress or I'll pay $800 excess, it took me 4 weeks 14 phone calls and I got the address, something budget could have got easily, still waiting since October 20th for settlement for very minor scratches and a 10 cent size dent. Never again with this company. I have a a Gold fully comprehensive cover and treated like this.

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Hi Danny, thankyou for taking the time to leave us… Read more

Recent reviews

Agha
AghaNSW40 posts
  Verified Gold Comprehensive

I made a claim where I was not responsible for the accident. I have had this insurance with Budget direct for 12 years and this was my first claim. I had a choice of repairer (in Miranda) but BD would not accept his quote and sent me to another one at Parramatta. BD then rejected Parramatta's claim and send me back to the Miranda one. Finally the… Read more

car got fixed and I was told there is no further action required on my part. With this experience, at renewal, I moved to another insurer.

So far BD have contacted (txt, email) me 10 times saying I missed the Miranda appointment. I called back, emailed, texted back - no impact. BD randomly called and wanted me to verify my id by giving my personal details which I refused as I did not know who was calling.

Does anyone know how to deal with pathetic service providers who keep wasting their and our money and patience.

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Good morning. I appreciate you posting this… Read more

Kristy
KristyNSW
  Gold Comprehensive

I would have given 5 stars but the wait time for roadside assistance is way too long. Twice now we have called and ended up paying for a private company to come out instead. Show details ·  1

Julia O.
Julia O.QLD
  Gold Comprehensive
Value for Money
Timeliness
Transparency

I've been with Budget Direct Car Insurance for as long as I've owned my car, and until June this year, I had never made a claim. Unfortunately, since lodging my first claim after being involved in a hit-and-run accident, the customer experience has been the worst I’ve ever encountered. Despite being told I wouldn't be charged the excess while… Read more

their recovery team investigated, Budget Direct has continued to pursue me for the payment. I provided all available evidence, including CCTV footage clearly showing the vehicle and driver responsible, yet six months later they claim they still can’t identify or contact the other party. Meanwhile, I receive constant calls and text messages demanding payment, while my emails to their recovery team go unanswered despite promises of follow-up. The lack of communication, accountability, and follow-through has been incredibly frustrating and disappointing. If this is how they treat loyal customers when they finally need support, I’d hate to see how they treat new ones.

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Hello Julia. I sincerely apologise for the… Read more

Car Insurance

Find out how Budget Direct Gold Comprehensive Car Insurance compares to other Car Insurance

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
Dee
Dee7 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

Really disappointed with the service I received on making a claim. I am told there are only 3 repairers for the whole area north of Perth that I can use. The furthest north being in Balcatta, not very far north at all. The repairer cannot schedule any work for 3 -4 weeks even if parts are available. The only option I am given is to be paid out… Read more

for the claim, and every time I phone I am required to listen to an extremely long recorded message. No idea how this company win any awards.

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Hi Dee. Thank you for taking the time to write your… Read more

42018arij
42018arij2 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

I'm writing review on behalf of my brother. Someone hit his car from back while it was parked on street . Its been more than a month so far . Even after numerous complaints to Budget Direct & after numerous conversations the issue hasn't been solved yet. Dragging towards lots & lots of weeks my time is wasting for nothing & its creating me huge… Read more

inconvenience without having my car in my brother's day to day life. Regretted a lot why he's with budget Direct when things takes too long to sortout. Please sortout the issues urgently & please don't take advantage of his goodness.

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Good morning, thank you for taking the time to… Read more

Kll
Kll2 posts
  Gold Comprehensive

Paid for gold comprehensive car insurance, that clearly states on multiple places on their website that car hire is included if you are at no fault accident. When need to claim they deny that this is included. Car was also maliciously damaged with police report. Repairs to the car will take 3 months. Completely misleading advertising. Completely… Read more

devoid of assistance. Complete rip off. Phone customer service claims staff were obstructive. No email reply when asking for further information or options for quicker repairs as she promised. Would not provide me with info who I could make a complaint to when asked for manager. I will be taking to the AFCA and the ACCC

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

We sincerely apologise for any inconvenience or… Read more

p7568831
p7568831NSW
  Gold Comprehensive

My friend was insured with the budget direct and he parked his car Infront of his home and some other car came and accident his car and he straight away call budget direct and made claim but they haven't approved his claim yet and getting him to go through stress situations. After looking him closely I decided to withdraw my policy from budget… Read more

direct and 3 of my friends also doing the same.

I try my best to spread the negligence of budget direct to as many people as I can.

This is the worst insurance which no one should be insured.

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Thank you for your feedback, We value our client’s… Read more

vasantha s.
vasantha s.
  Gold Comprehensive

Worst service not at all value the concern of the policy holder. It’s been almost 3 weeks I lodged the claim but they haven’t started investigating about the accident And very negligent answers. Making the policy holder stressful with their behaviour. The day I bought the policy I was with full hopes but now very regrettable about insured with the budget direct. Show details

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Good morning, thank you for taking the time to… Read more

Bhanu A.
Bhanu A.
  Gold Comprehensive

My friend’s car got hit by someone while he parked next to roadside parking. He hasn’t got the replacement car neither he got no response from the insurance company. He is uber driver surviving on the car but he hasn’t got the car back from them even after a month. I think this is no good car insurance company to be honest. I had an other friend with other car insurance, he got car three times hit by someone or vice verse in less than week. Show details

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Good morning, thank you for taking the time to… Read more

Audrey.
Audrey.
  Gold Comprehensive

Very patient and friendly assistant, explained everything to me in detail. Very happy with the quote. I’ve been with budget direct for some years now, never had to make a claim but if I ever do I trust that the process will be quick and easy. Show details ·  1

Krishna Kumar Duddu
Krishna Kumar DudduNSW3 posts
  Verified Gold Comprehensive

Very disappointed with the claim which is in progress. Claim raised on 18 April and till now they haven't provided an outcome. Their poor internal communications is causing frustration and delay to the overall processing. Assessor not going through case notes and assigning the vehicle to same repair who refused to repair due to air bad deployment.… Read more

Raise a complaint but it just a process on paper, no real progress they can make. I would give zero stars if there is an option. Have been with them for 6 yrs and never gonna consider them in future for all my insurance needs.

Budget Direct
Budget Direct    

Hello Krishna. I am so sorry to read that you've… Read more (+1 reply)

ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.