Review your last buy on ProductReview.com.au
McDonald Jones Homes

McDonald Jones Homes

 Verifiedmcdonaldjoneshomes.com.au
McDonald Jones Homes
4.7

2,286 reviews

Positive vs Negative
93%7%
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • See allThumbnail
Build Stage
  • Pre-Construction
  •  · 
  • Mid-Construction
  •  · 
  • Post-Construction
Customer Service
4.7
Site Admin ?
4.6
Timeliness
4.5
Structural Integrity
4.6
Plumbing & Waterproofing
4.5
Electrical & Lighting
4.6
Flooring
4.5
Transparency ?
4.5

 AI reviews summary 

Pros
Pre-construction guidance: Consultants are knowledgeable, patient, and thorough during the design and tender stages, helping to customise floor plans and manage budgets effectively.
Design studio experience: The selection process for internal and external finishes is well-organised, with consultants providing expert advice on colours, materials, and cohesive styling.
Construction communication: Site supervisors provide regular weekly updates and progress photos, maintaining clear and consistent contact throughout the building phase.
Project efficiency: Construction often progresses quickly, frequently meeting or exceeding estimated completion timeframes with well-coordinated trades.
Cons
Post-handover defect resolution: Resolving defects after practical completion is slow, with reports of repairs taking months or years to address and requiring repeated follow-up.
Communication after payment: Responsiveness and accountability from management and administrative staff decline significantly once the build moves past the initial stages or final payments are made.
Quality of workmanship: Issues occur with tiling, paint finishes, and structural compliance, sometimes requiring extensive rectification that disrupts occupancy.
Heating and cooling performance: Air conditioning systems in some regions are undersized for the home size, leading to inadequate temperature control in extreme weather.
Verdict

McDonald Jones Homes provides a highly professional and supportive experience during the planning and construction phases, backed by knowledgeable design staff and communicative site supervisors. However, the experience often deteriorates after handover, with significant delays in defect rectification and a lack of accountability regarding build quality and compliance issues. The contrast between the efficient pre-construction service and the slow post-completion support is a recurring point of friction.

Jose
Jose NSW
   Verified  NSW, Box Hill

I would like to commend Liam for his excellent service. He was knowledgeable, patient, responsive and took time to explain the queries/questions we had with regards to the special offers/contract. He also made sure that we would be invited to the VIP night though at that time we have not made our decision on which builder to go to. 

Ask the reviewer
Glen
Glen
   Verified  NSW, Baulkham Hills

We went to Norwest for our exterior selections and Jane was excellent in helping us select the colours, such a friendly and welcoming person. With her expertise, it made selecting the colours so much easier and fun. Thanks again Jane, we appreciate the help you gave us and it’s a shame I won’t have you helping us with the interior selections 

Ask the reviewer

Reviews with attachments

  • Thumbnail
Vicky
Vicky NSW
   Verified  NSW, Thornton

Five Stars – An Absolutely Wonderful Experience! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ We honestly cannot thank Emily enough for the incredible support, patience and guidance she has given us throughout our colour and design selections with McDonald Jones Homes. There were so many decisions to make, and at times we really struggled to decide what we wanted! Emily was absolutely amazing. Nothing was ever too much trouble, and her knowledge, creativity and genuine care made the whole experience so much easier and enjoyable.

She listened to our ideas, understood the look we were trying to achieve and helped bring our vision to life.

We even joked that we've created our very own design style along the way!

We walked away feeling so happy and excited about our beautiful new home.

Thank you, Emily, for going above and beyond. McDonald Jones Homes is very lucky to have you! ❤️

… 
  • Thumbnail
Kate Watt
Kate Watt 2 posts
   Verified  NSW, Thornton

We attended our Internal Selection Review today and had such a positive experience. Emily guided us through the whole process, showing us examples throughout the showroom and helping us visualise how different features would work in our home, including the bin drawer, which we think is going to be a fantastic addition to the kitchen! Emily has a brilliant eye for colour, tone and how different finishes will work together in real life. She really listened to our own ideas and preferences, then blended them with her expertise to help us make decisions we felt confident and excited about.

The whole appointment was incredibly well organised, right down to emailing us beforehand to choose what wrap we would like for lunch. Building a house and choosing all the different features is already exciting, but having someone knowledgeable, friendly and professional guiding you through it makes the experience even better. Thank you, Emily!

… 
  • Thumbnail
Sina
Sina NSW 3 posts
   Verified  NSW, Box Hill

We built our new home with McDonald Jones and had a great experience overall. Zaid was our supervisor throughout construction and he was great to deal with the whole way through. Communication was spot on, always responsive when we had questions, and he sent weekly updates so we always knew what was happening on site. The build moved along quickly and everything happened just as promised; no surprises.

Handover was smooth and we’re really happy with how everything turned out.

Would definitely recommend Zaid if you want a supervisor who actually delivers on what he says.

… 
  • Thumbnail
Jen W.
Jen W. 4 posts
   Verified  NSW, Thornton

From our first meeting with Kurt Hawkins in the Hunter sales office to working with Riley McNaughton, our site supervisor and Mandy Hardes, our administrative person, it’s been a wonderful experience which we are truly grateful for. This doesn’t mean there wasn’t the occasional ‘glitch’ but these were resolved quickly and fairly. During the important build phase both Riley and Mandy were very responsive to any questions and requests we had and we genuinely looked for to our weekly calls with Riley to update us on progress. This was very helpful to us as we don’t live locally and could not always do the ‘quick drive past to check on things’. Everyone has been very professional, knowledgeable and friendly. It is wonderful to deal with people who really seem to care. They are great ambassadors for McDonald Jones and we would have no hesitation in recommending McDonald Jones to anyone looking to build. Many thanks Jenny and Rob

… 
  • Thumbnail
Denise
Denise NSW 2 posts
   Verified  NSW

We have just finished all of our external, internal and electrical appointments. It definitely feels like an overwhelming situation but our consultants Elecia and Chloe were great! They were super helpful with options and easy to get along with. We made all of our decisions pretty easily and were happy with the outcome. Massive shout out to Elecia who was with us for all appointments and very efficient with all responses! 

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
joel D.
joel D.
   Verified  NSW, Leppington

Overall very positive experience with MJH. Our journey - signed build contract in May 2025 (Diane Alfar our sales agent was incredibly detailed, caring and found the right house and land package to meet all our desired needs and budget expectations. It was honestly with her planning and expectations setting we were able to avoid any budget deficits - build commenced in September 2025 - handover July 2026

The only hiccup we had in the entire build process was a 4 week delay due to our site supervisor unexpectedly quitting. I have to say Jerome the area manager stepped in with absolute certainty and got us back on track without compromising on quality. Also a shoutout to Bruce and Joe other (site managers) who were amazing.

$0 over budget and very happy with the home. Thank you MJH.

… 
  • Thumbnail
S W.
S W.
   Verified  NSW

Had such an amazing experience with Phoebe, she was so lovely and helpful. She made the experience so exciting for us! She also had such great experience and ideas for us to add which is what we really loved! I’m so glad we got to work with her and have such a great experience! 

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +5Thumbnail
Reno
Reno NSW 2 posts
   Verified  NSW, Thornton

We would like to share our very positive experience building our dual-occupancy property with McDonald Jones Homes. From the beginning of the journey through to completion, the overall experience was excellent. The process was professionally managed, communication was clear and consistent, and we always felt supported and informed about the progress of the build.

A special thank you must go to our Project Manager, Dale Baxter, who played a significant role in making the entire experience smooth and stress-free. Dale was approachable, responsive, and always willing to explain the different stages of construction clearly. He kept us informed, responded promptly to our questions, and ensured that any matters raised were followed up and resolved appropriately.

The quality of workmanship throughout the property was impressive. The team demonstrated excellent attention to detail, and the finishes were completed neatly and professionally. Quality, safety, and compliance were clearly treated as priorities throughout the construction process.

What stood out most was the end-to-end customer experience. Any questions, concerns, or minor issues were handled promptly and professionally. The level of support continued even after construction was completed, which gave us additional confidence and peace of mind.

Building a property, particularly a dual-occupancy development, can be a complex and stressful process. However, the professionalism, communication, coordination, workmanship, issue resolution, compliance, and ongoing support provided by McDonald Jones Homes made our experience genuinely positive.

We have already recommended McDonald Jones Homes to many of our friends, and several of them have now started their own building journeys with MJH. This reflects the level of confidence and satisfaction we have in the company and its team.

We are extremely satisfied with the completed property and would confidently recommend McDonald Jones Homes to anyone considering building a new home or investment property.

Our sincere thanks to Dale Baxter and the entire McDonald Jones Homes team for their dedication, professionalism, and support in successfully delivering our property. We would gladly choose MJH again for any future build.

… 
  • Thumbnail
Liz
Liz NSW
   Verified  NSW, Thornton

The internal selection day with Jenavee was a wonderful experience, we had plenty of time and was never rushed to make our selections. Time out to discuss and make informed decisions through out the day was incredibly helpful and relaxed. 

  • Thumbnail
aastral
aastral NSW
   Verified  NSW, Thornton

Our experience with the design team particularly Matt and Melissa at the design studio was wonderful. Both team members were extremely professional, well versed in their products and options that worked for our particular design ideas. Matt is a highly skilled and efficient person who made this experience truly enjoyable. 

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • +6Thumbnail
Anthony Sant
Anthony Sant NSW 4 posts
   Verified  NSW, Oak Flats

We have nothing but praise and admiration for the McDonald Jones Oak Flat Building Team, including the husband and wife sales team at Wongawilli. Due to the builds location and other council red tape, it has been a long journey and a difficult build for McDonald Jones. And I want to thank McDonald Jones for their persistence and support in getting the DA over the line. They have been really professional, supportive, empathetic helpfull and patient. And we must say they should be an inspiration to other builders. Their clientele support, communications, easy to talk & deal with, progress photos, and the quality of their workmanship and materials and pricing is all aimed at building and delivering a great and beautiful home for their clients. AND, what a house McDonald Jones is building us...... WOW !!! It is now approaching lock-up stage....and again, WOW !!!

I showed my brother, (a structural engineer) photos of the steel-frame of the house McDonald Jones is building us. And he was absolutely impressed and astounded by the amount of steel and steel frame thats gone into the building of the house. As he commented, " Great house to get away from the Big Bad Wolf."

I take my hat off, and put the entire McDonald Jones Team at Oak Flats and Wongiwilli up on the highest pedestal, from the beginning to the builds present stage.

Our build journey started with the husband and wife sales team at Wongawilli, George and Annslee. They are remarkable, and we soon developed a great rapport. Speaking of which this great rapport was extended right into the whole McDonald Jones Team at Oak Flats. George and Annslee helped and spoke with us about the correct design for our block and working within our budget. They also invited us to the Oak Flats office one evening, where we were shown videos, shown building materials and other construction items like; bench tops, door handles, basins etc. We were also introduced to a lot of other Oak Flat team members.

We then had an appointment to meet Ben at the Oak Flat office. Ben was great in helping us make the correct selection choices and styling for all the internals and externals, including appliances, kitchen, bench tops, door handles, cupboards, doors and colours and more.... And the way we chopped and changed, lucky, Ben is a very patient man .... haha ;). And all the other staff at the Oak Flat Office, including the friendly receptionists, Monique, Mrs. Lee, Allison, Bella G., and every single team member quietly working at back of house on plans, designs, sorting out council DA's etc etc. Thank you all for your professionalism and dedication.

After starting construction last October, the build has been full steam ahead. Great progress has been acheived and just about to lock up stage and we are so .... very excited !! Thanks to the two great building supervisors; namely George Pastrovic and Cameron Dagger. Thank you both for keeping us updated with your consistent uploading of progress photos to our profile. Great communication skills and general easy to work and get a long with attitude. Both George and Cameron have shown great professionalism and skills as building supervisors, liasoning with us and contractors. Ours was not an easy build, due to its difficult location. However, due to George and Cameron's tenacity and the support of the entire Oak Flat's Team, many issues and problems, were overcome. Again, I thank you all, for building our dream home come to fruition.

We also would like to say a BIG Thank You to all the contractors, sub-contractors and suppliers that McDonald Jones have chosen to contribute towards our build. They are the quiet achievers and they have been picked by McDonald Jones for their professionalism, and quality in workmanship.

And finally a big thank you also, to the McDonald Jones CEO Rob Douglas and all managers for running a great Building Company like McDonald Jones for your; Customer Service, Innovation, Building Designs and Plans, Professionalism, Flexability and making McDonald Jones Homes an Inspiration To Other Builders, that they could only wish to strive for, and setting a great standard for these other builders to strive for.

My wife and I have said it before, and we'll keep on saying it, " McDonalds Jones Is Too Good To Be True. Amazingly It's All True !!!

And to cap it off, again: Thank You So Much McDonald Jones

… 

Find out how McDonald Jones Homes compares to other Project Home Builders

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
  • Thumbnail
C.Weston
C.Weston 5 posts
   Verified  NSW, Baulkham Hills

We are very pleased with the quality of our McDonald Jones home and love how it has all come together. Wayne Gordon, our Construction Site Supervisor has delivered a high-quality build, and we are so pleased with the process. I had many questions throughout the construction process and they were always answered. Reaching practical completion there were only very minor superficial things that were picked up and these were addressed before handover. Wayne also went out of his way to do our handover before the long weekend, late on a Friday afternoon, so we could have our keys as soon as possible. Our friends and family have also commented on the quality of work and the high standard of the build. We felt very confident building with MJH due to their reputation and are happy with our choice. Mandy Hardes our Construction Coordinator was also extremely helpful along the way and was always on top of things. Through each stage, from our very first enquiry, MJH have been great to communicate with.

… 
  • Thumbnail
Margaretha
Margaretha NSW
   Verified  NSW, Baulkham Hills

Thank you so much Mcdonald Jones especially James Evans the one that been helping us since day one through everything and no drama, everything done as we expected to be done, sooner than we thought, very happy with the results. Once again Thank you again James and Mcdonald Jones. 

  • Thumbnail
Shimin L
Shimin L NSW
   Verified  NSW, Braemar

I ' m a Chinese guest and my English is not particularly good . I have to use translation software to better understand every detail . But I was a very lucky guest to meet Jack and Tracey . They are professional consultants and very patient in explaining . When I didn ' t understand something , they would use translation , pictures and other methods to make me realize that McDonald Jones ' sample room is my dream home . Whether it ' s the quality of the building or the color and style matching , it ' s everything I want , so I chose this place without hesitation . They will lead me through my house - building journey . I believe everything will be a wonderful memory .

… 
  • Thumbnail
Michelle
Michelle NSW 4 posts
   Verified  NSW

I want to share our experience building a home with McDonald Jones. Our house is a dual occupancy property, and the construction took around six months. Initially, we were only going to build the house, but we decided to upgrade to a full-turnkey package that included everything—and I’m so glad we did. Throughout the entire process, Dale, our project manager, kept us updated weekly. Everything ran smoothly from start to finish. Before we knew it, the house was complete, and it was time for the final inspection. Dale was incredible. He guided us through every detail, explaining everything clearly and celebrating the completion of our home with us. Every part of the work by McDonald Jones was meticulous—far beyond our expectations. From the tiles to the grouting, down to every bit of silicone, everything was finished neatly and with exceptional quality. What really sets McDonald Jones apart isn’t just the construction itself. Since this was our first investment property, we had little to no knowledge about the process, but they guided us on real estate decisions and recommended everything we needed. Any minor issues in the house were addressed immediately. Even two months after completion, I am still extremely satisfied with the communication and support they provided throughout. If we ever build another house, there’s no question—we would choose McDonald Jones again. A heartfelt thank you to Dale for turning our dream into reality, and to his entire team for their dedication. Special thanks to Lili in the office for all the help along the way. And to everyone at McDonald Jones who worked tirelessly from start to finish to make sure our home was completed flawlessly—thank you so much.

… 

Latest follow-ups

  • Thumbnail
Eddie
Eddie NSW 4 posts
 Published  · Edited   Verified  NSW, Leppington

Defects after defects – This is a pre contruction review, at the moment we are happy on how MJH did it. From the signing the Tender with Diane & Maria which turns smooth, Diane continue to email me and check how we go. Then to the appointments, theres lots of variations that very disappointin but will come but they will help you just for a bit. With the start of the construction when your home is taking shape you will be amazed on how good the workmanship of MJH, Thanks to Wayne Gordon our site supervisor who handles it, we know its not finish yet but he guarantee to me that he will look after it and make the built faultless and says if there is issue he will rectify it straight away.

He also always email me every week on how the build is going. Thanks Wayne, I hope your promise will make our home a 5 star home..

… 

 Follow-up  · More defects after the hand over. Paint job wast worst, window frame from outside was bad, rusting electrical box. They fix some defects but the major once hasnt been touch. Site Supervisor was not that serious on some issues thay we raised during the built, grout in kitchen is not the colour we agreed, its nearly 2 years and major defects hasnt been fix. I waited but they are slow. I will post a youtube on the two years anniv if major defects wasnt fix by that time.

McDonald Jones Homes
McDonald Jones Homes    

Hi Edward, thank you for your lovely review.…  (+2 replies)

Sean
Sean NSW 5 posts
   Verified  NSW, Baulkham Hills

I recommend being very careful when signing documents and, if possible, seeking independent advice from an experienced builder or building professional before making final selections. This was my first time building a house, and I chose MJH because I understood them to be one of the more established building companies in New South Wales. I expected the building process to be straightforward and believed that the selections and requirements I discussed with their staff would be properly recorded and delivered.

Before signing the contract, I clearly communicated my expectations and discussed several specific requirements with their team. Some requests could not be accommodated, which I understood, while other requirements were discussed, agreed to and paid for.

Unfortunately, after construction began, and particularly after handover, I encountered several issues.

Bathroom basin

The basin installed in the bathroom was not the basin I understood I had selected at the design appointment. I was told that I had signed off on the item and therefore had to accept it.

When I reviewed the contract, I found that the brand and model specified were different from the item I remembered selecting. I also asked about the staff member who assisted me at the design appointment and was told she was no longer working with the company.

Bathroom handles

I selected gold fixtures for the bathroom, but silver cabinet handles were installed. They did not match the other fixtures.

I raised the issue with MJH and was told that the handles were my selection. I ultimately purchased replacement handles myself and had them changed.

Damaged basin

One of the basins was also installed with significant damage, including a large hole. I raised the issue but was not satisfied with the response regarding its replacement.

This contributed to significant delays, and the handover was delayed by more than six months.

I have now been living in the house for approximately 18 months, and some of the defects and issues I raised remain unresolved.

Office wall panels

Another issue was the installation of wall panels in my office. I had not ordered these panels and clearly told MJH that I had never requested them.

Despite this, I was told that the work had been carried out and that I was required to pay for it. I was unhappy that I was being charged for something I had specifically said I had not ordered.

Coffered ceiling

The most significant issue for me concerns the coffered ceiling.

Before construction, I clearly explained to several MJH staff members what I wanted. I showed them photographs and explained that the purpose of the coffered ceiling was to accommodate LED lighting.

I was told that MJH could provide what I had requested, and I paid approximately an additional $10,000 for the work. I was also told that the necessary preparation and wiring would be provided and that I would arrange for my own electrician to install the LED lights.

After handover, I engaged electricians to install the lighting. They advised me that, in their opinion, the coffered ceiling had not been constructed in a way that would allow the lighting installation I had intended, but that the wiring was ready for the installation of LED lights.

I contacted MJH and initially understood that they would look into the issue. After several months, however, a manager told me that the coffered ceiling provided was the only type of coffered ceiling MJH offered.

I then provided emails showing my discussions with MJH staff about my requirements and the additional amount I paid. I remain dissatisfied with the way this matter has been handled.

One of the difficulties I have experienced is that some of the requirements discussed during the design process are difficult to verify simply by looking at the final building contract. In my experience, this made it very important to keep copies of emails, selections, photographs and other records.

Current situation

I raised my concerns with the relevant building authority or commission, but I was advised that they could not resolve the matter and that I should consider seeking legal advice.

I have not engaged a solicitor because I understand it could be costly. I am concerned about the financial burden of pursuing the matter further, and I believe most builders know that customers are unlikely to take matters to a solicitor because of the cost involved.

I am sharing this review because this has been my personal experience during and after building my home with MJH. My main advice to anyone considering building with any company is to carefully check every selection, specification and variation before signing; keep copies of all emails and documents; and consider getting independent advice before agreeing to significant variations or additional costs.

I hope my experience helps other first-time home builders understand the importance of keeping detailed records and ensuring every requirement is clearly documented.

… 

 Follow-up  · They asked me to provide photos of the defects that still haven't been rectified. They also said that, according to their records, they have fixed all defects and that two years have already passed. However, they seem to be focusing only on the defects and completely ignoring the ceiling issue. I get the impression that they still have no… 

McDonald Jones Homes
McDonald Jones Homes    

Hi Sean, we have sent you a private message.

jibinbabu2023
jibinbabu2023
   Verified  NSW, Warnervale

We are having an amazing pre-construction experience so far with MCJ Homes. We approached Mitchel with a specific time constraint for our home build due to a last-minute complication with another builder. Mitchel was ready for the challenges we presented and successfully met all the promised timeframes during the pre-construction process, especially with preparing the tender required for the bank. He even assisted us while he was off work when the bank requested additional documents just before the final settlement for the land, as we were applying under the 5% deposit scheme.

Mitchel also helped us design the home we wanted, accommodating the multiple changes we requested along the way. He explained and demonstrated these changes using live examples from the display home, which really helped us understand the practicality of what we were requesting.

The final cost compared to the original tender had only marginal changes, which I believe can vary depending on individual circumstances such as soil tests, BAL rating, and other site conditions.

Mitchel, Linda, and the entire team we have dealt with so far have been highly professional and knowledgeable in their respective fields.

We are currently awaiting CDC approval, which is taking slightly longer than the usual processing time. We are hopeful that construction will begin as soon as all the documentation is finalised.

… 

 Follow-up  · Construction of our home (Job #211153) commenced on 21 April 2026. At the time of signing the contract, the average build time for a single-storey home on the Central Coast was indicated to be around 160-170 business days, excluding delays due to adverse weather. Our project has incurred approximately 7-8 business days of weather-related… 

McDonald Jones Homes
McDonald Jones Homes    

Thank you for such a lovely review. We are… 

In-depth reviews

Amanda E
Amanda E NSW
   Verified  NSW, Baulkham Hills

We chose MJH from the very beginning because, compared to the many other builders we met with, their professionalism, transparency and quality were immediately apparent. We have had the pleasure of meeting many wonderful MJH employees throughout our journey so far, but we would particularly like to acknowledge Gary (our Tender and Plan Presenter) and Lorraine (our Internal Selections Consultant). If we could give Gary and Lorraine a 6-star rating, we absolutely would!

When we first met with Gary, there were a few outstanding items from the previous stage of the process that needed to be addressed. He captured everything accurately, including matters that were outside his direct role or responsibility, and ensured all the required changes were incorporated. His attention to detail was exceptional. This saved us multiple rounds of back-and-forth discussions and made finalising the design a much smoother process.

Gary's professionalism, responsiveness and ability to get things right the first time made the entire process efficient and stress-free. His ability to understand our requirements, proactively address outstanding issues and ensure nothing was overlooked gave us a great deal of confidence throughout this stage of our journey.

Lorraine stepped in to assist us with our internal selections appointment when unforeseen circumstances meant our original consultant was unable to meet with us. She guided us through what can at times feel like an overwhelming process, with so many decisions to make. She patiently listened to all of my many questions and came up with fantastic ideas, solutions and suggestions, all while keeping our individual budget requirements in mind.

It was immediately clear that Lorraine has an incredible depth of knowledge and experience. We are so grateful for her guidance and for helping us arrive at selections that we are genuinely happy with.

Lorraine also went above and beyond to find a solution to an issue that I had been quite upset about. She handled the situation with such professionalism, empathy and care, making sure we felt heard and valued. This really meant a lot to us.

Both Gary and Lorraine have made a very positive impact on our building journey, and we are incredibly grateful for their efforts. They are a credit to MJH, and we hope their contributions are recognised.

… 
Thiags
Thiags 3 posts
   Verified  NSW, Baulkham Hills

Building a new home is one of the biggest milestones in life, and choosing the right builder and having the right site supervisor can make all the difference. We are incredibly happy and grateful to McDonald Jones Homes (MJH) for making our entire home-building journey such a smooth, positive and memorable experience. We signed our contract in September 2025 and received the keys to our beautiful new home in October 2026. From the beginning through to handover, the entire process was well managed, and we couldn't be happier with the experience.

The biggest highlight of our journey was undoubtedly our exceptional Site Supervisor, Zaid Loraichi.

It is rare to come across someone who combines professionalism, genuine care, honesty, integrity and dedication to their work as naturally as Zaid does.

From the moment he took responsibility for our build, Zaid gave us complete confidence that our home was in the best possible hands. He was always approachable, friendly, considerate, patient and, above all, genuinely committed to delivering a quality home.

What truly set Zaid apart was his outstanding communication. Almost every week, without us having to chase him, he kept us informed of the construction progress through messages, photographs and regular updates. This transparency meant so much to us, especially during a process where homeowners can often feel anxious or uncertain about what is happening on-site.

Zaid was proactive, responsive and always willing to answer our questions. He never made us feel that our concerns were too small or unimportant. He listened, explained things clearly and made sure we felt comfortable and informed throughout the journey.

His commitment to quality was equally impressive. He paid attention to the details, maintained high standards and made sure the work was completed properly, without compromising on quality. He took genuine ownership of the project and treated our home with the care and responsibility we would expect from someone building their own.

Another remarkable aspect was his ability to keep the project on schedule. Despite the complexities that can come with building a new home, Zaid ensured that construction progressed efficiently and that our home was delivered on time, without unnecessary delays.

What we appreciated most, however, was not just his technical knowledge or project management skills, but the kind of person he is. Zaid is genuinely honest, trustworthy, respectful and thoughtful. His sincerity and dedication were evident in every interaction. He made what could have been a stressful experience feel reassuring and enjoyable.

We genuinely feel blessed and fortunate to have had Zaid as our Site Supervisor. He is an incredible asset to McDonald Jones Homes, and anyone fortunate enough to have him supervising their build is in exceptionally good hands.

We would also like to sincerely thank the broader MJH team for making the process seamless, well coordinated and enjoyable, from signing the contract through to receiving our keys.

A beautiful home is the end result, but the people who help you get there are what make the journey truly special. For us, Zaid made that difference.

Thank you, Zaid, for your hard work, patience, integrity, dedication and genuine care. We will always remember and appreciate the role you played in bringing our dream home to life.

We wholeheartedly recommend McDonald Jones Homes, and we cannot speak highly enough of Zaid Loraichi. He truly deserves recognition for the exceptional work he does and the positive difference he makes to his customers.

Thank you, Zaid and MJH, for making our dream home a reality!

… 

Find out how McDonald Jones Homes compares to other Project Home Builders

Know better, choose better.

Compare all
  • Thumbnail
Rani
Rani NSW
   Verified  NSW, Baulkham Hills

McDonald Jones Homes – A Dream Home That Has Become a Nightmare I could write a hundred reviews about my experience with McDonald Jones Homes, and none of them would truly describe what I’ve been through. Unless you’ve experienced something similar, it’s hard to understand how exhausting and disappointing this journey has been. Imagine spending 18 months just getting through pre-construction, dealing with design mistakes, BASIX delays, incorrect variation calculations, endless corrections and paperwork. You finally reach construction and think, surely the worst is over.

Unfortunately, the nightmare was only beginning.

You visit your site hoping to see progress, but nothing has changed. You return the following week. Still nothing. Sometimes four weeks pass without a single worker showing up. My home was left untouched for four weeks because of a scaffolding issue.

At this point, it genuinely feels like construction is scheduled for one day a week. And if it happens to rain that day? There goes another entire week.

The irony is almost unbelievable. Months of delays pass with barely an explanation, yet when it rains for ONE DAY, a formal notice arrives immediately to extend the construction period. I wish they were as efficient at building homes as they are at documenting delays.

My brother chose another builder. His home right next door is already finished. Meanwhile, I’m still waiting and wondering when I’ll finally see consistent progress.

The worst part isn’t even the waiting anymore. It’s the feeling that nobody cares how much this is affecting your life. The constant chasing, the unanswered questions, the broken expectations and the disappointment every time you visit your empty building site.

People see an unfinished house. They don’t see the months of stress behind it.

I wouldn’t wish this building experience on anyone.

McDonald Jones Homes, I didn’t pay for excuses, silence or endless waiting. I trusted you to build my home.

At this point, I’m not even asking when my dream home will be finished. I’m wondering when building it will actually become a priority.

… 
McDonald Jones Homes
McDonald Jones Homes    

Hello Rani, we have passed on your feedback… 

Positive reviews

Michael.
Michael. 2 posts
   Verified  NSW, Oak Flats

We recently went through the pre-construction stage with McDonald Jones Homes and were really impressed with how smooth and professional everything was. From the first consultation, the team took the time to understand exactly what we wanted in our new home. The design process felt collaborative rather than rushed — they listened carefully to our ideas, offered practical suggestions, and helped us refine the floor plan until it felt right.

Overall, the pre-construction stage felt organised, supportive, and genuinely customer-focused. It set a strong foundation heading into the build. If you’re considering McDonald Jones Homes, the early stages alone make a great first impression.

… 
tatenda s.
tatenda s. NSW 5 posts
   Verified  NSW, Thornton

We have been working with Carissa as our Project Consultant at McDonald Jones Homes since completing our plans review, as she has guided our project through the various pre-construction requirements leading up to the development application lodgement. It has not been an entirely straightforward process, with several challenges and a fair amount of back and forth, particularly around external selections and BASIX compliance requirements.

What has stood out to us is Carissa’s willingness to explore practical solutions, liaise with the relevant teams and consultants, and present options that help bring the project into compliance with the necessary requirements.

Throughout this process, she has also been mindful of the financial implications of proposed changes, working to minimise additional costs while preserving as much as possible of our original design preferences and vision for our home.

Overall, it has been a positive experience working with Carissa so far. We appreciate her efforts throughout this stage and look forward to continuing to work with her as our project progresses towards construction.

… 
Samantha C.
Samantha C. NSW
   Verified  NSW, Oak Flats

We have had the most wonderful experience with the MJH team and having Ben appointed as our design consultant for our selections at the Oak Flats studio has been the cherry on top. The studio selection process can be an overwhelming and daunting experience and Ben immediately made us feel at ease with his open and welcoming nature. He took the time to guide us through the process of making our selections with patience, thoughtfulness and consideration. He takes the time to listen to your ideas/preferences and offers a range of possibilities at different price points. He is a highly experienced consultant with extensive knowledge of the building industry and available products. We are so grateful for our experience with Ben and the amazing Oak Flats Studio team.

… 

Negative reviews

VRai
VRai NSW
   Verified  NSW, Box Hill

I would not recommend this builder based on my experience. They presented grand plans for the home, I signed the contract, and paid a $5,000 deposit. Immediately after signing, I was told the plan we had agreed upon was no longer applicable due to council guidelines. I asked what checks had been done before signing the contract and taking the deposit, and why the plan’s suitability for the land had not been verified beforehand. I requested they submit for DA approval, but they refused outright, stating they only work through CDC.

What I find most frustrating is that we spent months finalising floor plans and modifications, and at no point was I told the plan would not be approved.

When I requested a refund of my deposit, they refused, citing a “change of mind.” After months of back-and-forth correspondence, they agreed to refund approximately one-quarter of the deposit.

Please proceed carefully if you are considering this builder. Before signing, they are very accommodating, but once the contract is signed, the attitude changes markedly.

I lost my hard-earned money and regret the day I decided to go with them for my dream home.

… 
Antony H
Antony H 3 posts
   Verified  NSW, Port Macquarie

This company is a joke!! House build was disgracefully slow with poor quality workmanship and now we are still awaiting defects list to be completed 18 months after it was submitted. This company has a high turnover of staff and there is absolutely no care factor or accountability. I am looking at legal options now and I know there are many more in mid north coast area who have had a similarly poor experience with this company. There are a few in my street alone who I have been speaking with in relation to legal options. Would love to hear from anyone else who has suffered at the hands of this company which seems to promise a lot but arguably rarely delivers. Might be time for a class action perhaps.

… 
McDonald Jones Homes
McDonald Jones Homes    

Hello Antony, can you please share your build number so we can follow this up for you?

donn c.
donn c. NSW
   Verified  NSW

This guy asked me to review him and give him a 5 star review. After that he gave us a nightmare!! Poor communications. I was expecting that our dream house will be a very good experience! But this guy gave us a VERY BAD EXPERIENCE!! no updates! No call backs if we replace ask him. PLEASE IF YOU HAVE THIS GUY! Ask for someone else!! Worst experience ever!!! Just helping you guys out. Otherwise McDonald jones team is amazing and re assuring! Hope this review will help. 

McDonald Jones Homes
McDonald Jones Homes    

Hi Donn, This feedback is quite concerning… 

Recent reviews

Matty L.
Matty L.
   Verified  NSW, Lochinvar

Rob and Emily were fantastic helping us through the 1st stage of our build. They are 2 of the nicest people and madr it feel more personal to deal with them 

Loi N.
Loi N. 2 posts
   Verified  NSW, Thornton

I worked with Kayley Mullen, the internal selection consultant. She is really professional, nice, helpful and patient. We believe we have chosen the right items for our dream home thanks to her big help 

Laura J
Laura J NSW
   Verified  NSW, Thornton

Efficient and professional, Kayley provided an excellent service today. She had great product knowledge and really helped us feel confident to make bold choices and go with our hearts! We are very excited to see our dream home come together. 

Taylor Groves
Taylor Groves
   Verified  NSW, Baulkham Hills

Finished our exterior selections with our consultant Chloe. She has been amazing every step of the way and is a very knowledgeable & bubbly lady. Would highly recommended McDonald Jones Customer service, 10/10 

  • Thumbnail
Lane S.
Lane S. NSW 3 posts
   Verified  NSW, Port Macquarie

House is at the 11 months of build time and is not up to lockup stage.Four to five days a month is all that is spent on site. Paying for a premium service and quality all we get is lip service, if we had known this there is no way we would be doing a knock down rebuild. 

CChristine
CChristine NSW
   Verified  NSW, Baulkham Hills

We were lucky to have Dani from BH Sydney office to assist us with both our internal and external selections. Dani was more than happy to review options with us which helped in finalising the best style/colour for the look we were going for. Dani also helped us with costings along the way which my mum extremely appreciated This made the process so much easier for us. Thankyou for all your help Dani! Effy & Christine 

ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.

©  ProductReview.com.au Pty. Ltd. All Rights Reserved. General disclaimer: All third party trademarks, images and copyrights on this page are used for the purpose of comparative advertising, criticism or review. This is a public forum presenting user opinions on selected products and businesses, and as such the views expressed do not reflect the opinion of ProductReview.com.au. Further details in the disclaimer.