Best Cosmetic Products for Eyes

Based on 1,120 reviews
Brand
Search brand…
Rating
Product Type

My Perfect Eyes

My Perfect Eyes

2.9 Summary
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • See allThumbnail
RobynNSW
  Fair Incentive Verified

Dear Ena I have been more than happy with the various products I have purchased. I have never used any other products with My Perfect Eyes, weather… Read more

conditions have had no effect when using this product. The masks have improved my appearance. Ena, I greatly appreciated your assistance in answering my concerns.

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • See allThumbnail
Dach GideonNSW3 posts
 

Picked this up for my wife during the Black Friday sales and she’s been pretty pleased with it. The serum goes on easily, doesn’t sting, and dries… Read more

quick. After a few weeks her lashes looked a bit fuller and healthier. Nothing over the top, just a nice, steady result she’s happy with.

kaylajjxo3 posts
 

Amazing mascara – Everyone always ask me what mascara I use, this make my lashes long. Show details

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
Hayleigh PNSW2 posts
  Verified

I am in love with these lashes!! The application process was so smooth and the lash styles are absolutely gorgeous. They look exactly like real… Read more

eyelash extensions even though they’re simply clusters. Shipping was fast and customer service via their instagram account was friendly and very helpful! I highly recommend this brand.

  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • See allThumbnail
Fiona M.
 

Satisfied – I love how fast the delivery was and the package came with no damages also I love the product it is very easy apply even for beginners Show details

Jessica W.WA
 

Don't waste your money! – I had high hopes for this eyelash enhancer, but unfortunately, it was a huge disappointment. After using it for a few weeks, I started experiencing… Read more

severe eye irritation and redness, which later turned into an eye infection. My eyes became swollen and itchy, and I had to stop using the product immediately.

Not only did it cause discomfort, but I also saw no noticeable improvement in my lashes. If anything, my lashes felt more brittle than before. The formula also left a sticky residue on my lash line, making my eyes feel heavy and uncomfortable.

For the price, I expected a safe and effective product, but instead, I ended up with irritated eyes and wasted money. I do not recommend this product at all! If you have sensitive eyes, stay far away from this!

Shannon B55 posts
 

Expensive but is an excellent product – Bought this at Mecca and really enjoyed using it. Great colour for lighter eyebrows. Solid Pencil that felt like good quality and a long lasting and… Read more

consistent colour. Lasted a year with daily wear to work. Expensive and have been looking for cheaper options but the pencils are flimsy and wear out quickly. Will likely go back to this one as a solid performer.

DaniNSW9 posts
 

LOVEEEEE – I LOVE THIS MASCARA SO MUCH. so much volume and it separates every lash. Show details

Dontgetakitty12 posts
 

Smudges! oh no not good – Happy to see a truer rating here on productreview. I’ve tried so many mascaras and this just isn’t the hype. I even tried again recently and instantly regretted. Smudging is terrible and no length or curl. So many better options. Show details

Thiphawan A.
 

I love this product so much – I been using it for 2 weeks and I noticed the difference my lashes have gotten longer and thicker. Show details

Bella KWA16 posts
 

Smudgy mess . Yuck – Didn't like this AT ALL. when trying to apply it kept smudging on the top of my eyelid . A smudgy mess. Yuck.

Angry Momma4 posts
 

Beautiful pallet! – Simple answer: Beautiful pallets of coordinated colors that stay on very nice through out the entire working day and also wash off very easily with only soap and water no harsh scrubbing! Show details

Maybelline Tattoo Brow

Maybelline Tattoo Brow

2.0 Summary
AnnSA9 posts
 

Only a tiny tip that fell off during first use so unable to test. Pitiful waste of money. Mabelline should be ashamed for producing such junk. Thought I was purchasing a propelling device. No, just 2mm tip. Show details

Luxe Lashlift Set

Luxe Lashlift Set

2.8 Summary
Sarah
 

I was sceptical at first, but I did order. I received my set and absolutely love it. so much easier than I thought, and I managed to do it all with a… Read more

3.5yr old throwing demands at me every 2 minutes. My eye lashes look great and day to day I don't need to wear mascara but when I do oh wow, they look professionally done and amazing. The only issue is I ordered the buy one get one free but never received my free pack and the only contact for them is an email which keeps bouncing back so there is no way of getting ahold of the company.

Johns Suit DusterQLD42 posts
 

Out of all eye shadows expensive to cheap bys is my favourite !!! – I have this pallette but so many others too. They have such a wide range of bright ones, matte colours, brown colours, grape and summer colours. It… Read more

does not affect my eyes whatsoever as I have sensitive eyes and the colour stays on all day! I would of not expected much from a brand that costs around 10 dollars. I trust this brand more than the more expensive brands. Kmart now have many more ranges of the bys eye shadow palettes so definitely check it out! Very versatile and good quality.

UK Lash

UK Lash

1.9 Summary
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • Thumbnail
  • See allThumbnail
SarahVIC5 posts
 

Do not use this - the first one I used was ok, minimal growth so I continued. I got a few small infections by the time I was onto the second vial, so… Read more

took a break from the product. When it was clear I started again, and now eyes are completely inflamed, with lashes falling out. Their customer care team is a disaster.

Kyra2 posts
 

All shades baby!!! – This brow pencil is actual magic, works with every brow colour like ever!?!?! I trialled it on a bunch of my pals with various colour brows and it was so fab!

Margene B.NSW6 posts
 

Ahava Mineral Hand Cream – I was seeking a hand cream, that was cruelty free, smooth and creamy but not oily or greasy, I was searching on the website I normally… Read more

use..Activeskin and found a product reasonably price called Ahava. I looked at the product content and found it was a product I could use as it did not contain nuts. So I thought I will it go. Its good product, fresh smelling, smells like the sea, cool and non-greasy, which is great. I love the packaging. I am surprised with the size of the product and feel that it's value for money. I will definitely look into their other products.

Liv8 posts
 

Meh – This is super volumising and thickening but doesn’t coat the length of my lashes. It looks pretty clumpy especially up close and flakes and transfers… Read more

under my eyes even though I don’t put it there. It works, but I’ll continue on my hunt for a natural-looking mascara that plays to my lashes’ strengths.

Sharon S.WA8 posts
 

Meh not that great – It glides on easily but it’s definitely not 100% waterproof or smudge proof. You’d expect an eyeliner advertised as waterproof and smudge proof to… Read more

not budge when you break a bit of a sweat in the gym or when it’s humid outside. This eyeliner failed me on both occasions.

GBT S.11 posts
 

BEST MASCARA IVE EVER USED – Im mature age. I look stupid with false lashes. Im trained yrs ago as beauty therapist & make up artist in Syd. Wrote beauty column for newspaper.… Read more

Just despaired of finding waterproof black mascara that made my lashes look long & full! Ive tried just about everything out there for years. Then I found Max Factor False Lash Effect mascara 2 wks ago at Big W of all places. It is SENSATIONAL! Def waterproof. Makes lashes look long & thick. Doesnt glug or clump!

Kym9 posts
 

It really works amazing – Finally an eyelash growth serum that works. In 6 weeks I've gone from having fine, sparse, short lashes to these thick strong & really long lashes… Read more

they dont even feel like mine as I've never had good lashes. People are now commenting on their length...im totally impressed. All natural product with no side effects like many love it!

Susan C.2 posts
 

As a nurse, I am very cognizant of germs and bacteria. This mascara comes in a package of three for a monthly trade out without having to keep up… Read more

with when “do I replace my old mascara.?” Our make up brushes and wands are full of bacteria, this company has perfected an option not only for those of us sensitive to products, but also who may experience frequent styes from blocked glands. And to top it off, the mascara works beautifully! I highly recommend this product and am so grateful for the creator.

KayNSW23 posts
 

It's great to wake in the mornings, look in the mirror and not see a Panda staring back. Finally! a mascara which doesn't streak with watery eyes and… Read more

is removed gently with a facial wipe without leaving any residue. I've tried numerous methods of removing Waterproof Mascara over the years without complete success but Mabeline WASHABLE Mascara has finally arrived ... YEY!

Delilah Eye Line

Delilah Eye Line

5.0 Summary
APPLEASHA132 posts
 

A great eyeliner – I bought this retractable eyeliner at Fortuum & Mason when I was in London. Excellent eyeliner. Doesn’t smudge, stays on, excellent pigment and comes… Read more

off well with micellar water. I use face oil now and it does smudge a little because of the oil but not as much as most eyeliners

EvonneVIC3 posts
 

Perfect – I love this mascara, have tried and tested so many. It doesn’t smudge, clump or flake and lasts all day. Easy to apply and easy to remove with micellar water.

EmAyeTeaQLD74 posts
  Verified

I think I have found the product for me. one – 2 easy steps 1. apply wax to shape & fix. 2. Layer powder to set. Comes with pro brushes for precise application. I've got a draw full of eyebrow… Read more

Sculpting products and this is the one that's just right. My eyebrows are quite sparse on the outer edges and this fills that space in well. I chose the dark brown shade

HaroldQLD23 posts
 

Outstanding product – This is the closest replacement to Butterfly Mascara Sculpt. Happy to use it. Only wish they would go back to ordinary brushes and not the plastic type which do not work as well

Skye88NSW11 posts
 

Voluptuous lashes – If you want gorgeous voluptuous lashes this is the mascara for you, volume and length crating lashes that really define the eye and make your eye colour pop. Been through 4 tubes already. Highly recommend  Show details

beezeeQLD83 posts
 

Not reputable. Do not respond to emails. Placed a large order several weeks ago. Half shipped. Half did not. Despite repeated emails they dont… Read more

respond. They just kept my money and didnt dispatch the goods. Will be initiating a credit card dispute if I am unable to contact them.

beezee
beezee   

Update. After leaving multiple negative reviews and comments on social media I did eventually get… Read more

alt_text

Best ingredients for the eyes

The way to get glowing and healthy skin is to choose products that have natural ingredients which moisturise, strengthen and lift the sensitive skin around our eyes instead of irritating them.

Here is a great list of ingredients you should keep an eye out for when choosing cosmetic products for your eyes:

  • Peptides: Peptides support collagen production and are a good choice for those with thinning skin and fine lines.
  • Ceramides: Ceramides refine the tightness of, and add moisture to, the skin.
  • Hyaluronic acid: Hyaluronic acid attracts water which moisturises the skin and improves its elasticity.
  • Alpha hydroxy acids (AHAs): AHAs like lactic acid, glycolic acid and mandelic acid can reduce the effects of hyperpigmented skin.
  • Vitamin C: Vitamin C is an antioxidant that grants sun protection and brightening properties.
  • Vitamin E: Vitamin E is a moisturising and soothing vitamin.
  • Retinoids: Also known as Vitamin A, retinoids can reduce the appearance of wrinkles but increase sensitivity to the skin and therefore should only be used in the evening. They can also irritate the skin, so only use retinoid products designed specifically for the undereye.
  • Green tea: Puffy eyes in the morning? Fret not since caffeine and tannin naturally have anti-inflammatory properties that can reduce dark circles.
  • SPF: This ingredient is key to preventing sun damage and wrinkles around your eyes.

What to look for when buying a mascara

Most of us that wear make-up would agree that a good mascara is essential to perfecting any look. Our eyes frame our face; by lifting and darkening our eyelashes, we can brighten our faces, rejuvenate our eyes when we are tired and make them stand out. A bold eye-look is often complemented by a precise eyeliner and eyeshadow.

Here are some things you should watch out for when buying mascara:

Easy application

The applicator brush will determine how easy the mascara will be to apply without getting any clumps or smudging it. This includes scoping out the size, shape and material of the wand for the most comfortable experience. Wands can be shaped in many ways to catch each eyelash more easily.

Thin brushes tend to be the best for lengthening since they can get under your lashes the easiest. Thicker brushes will create a more voluminous look but make sure it is the right size for your eye to avoid clumping. Look for a wand that is densely packed and has a pointed tip for easy, clean application. Choosing a well-designed brush will also reduce the chance of you accidentally poking yourself in the eye or smudging your application.

Long-lasting

The way to making sure your mascara lasts all day is to look for high-quality ingredients that provide adequate colour, length and hold. There is little more annoying than having your mascara go flat and having to reapply it, leading to product build-up.

Easy to remove

While we may want our mascaras to be long-lasting and waterproof, we also need them to be easy to remove with the right products. To avoid damaging your eyelashes trying to remove mascara by scrubbing endlessly, look for a water-soluble formula for everyday wear and save the waterproof mascaras for special occasions.

Quick-drying

When you’re running late, the last thing you need is a slow-drying mascara that smudges when you move around. This is an especially important factor to consider if you’re applying more than one coat and need to wait for each coat to dry before applying the next.

Hydrating

Many cheap mascaras clump up easily, this is because they don’t have moisturising ingredients in them or they have hard-to-use applicator wands. Keep an eye on the ingredients list to ensure they’re full of rich, moisture-boosting ingredients instead of sulphates and parabens which are likely to dry out your lashes and make them more brittle.

Do eyelash serums work?

If you’re a big fan of eyelash extensions, lash lifts and false lashes, you might be interested to know that you can get the same look at home completely naturally.

Eyelash serums promote thicker and fuller eyelash growth through the use of certain ingredients such as peptides and hyaluronic acid. They’re applied topically and can also work in conjunction with eyelash conditioners which restore moisture to your lashes and strengthen them.

They normally take up to 12 weeks of daily use to work and may not be suitable for those with sensitive eyes and skin since they need to be applied from the root of your lashes.

Hair growth supplements

You could try taking a hair growth supplement if you’re looking to lengthen your lashes and thicken up your brows. The supplements tend to contain collagen which is good for both hair growth and for keeping the skin looking plump. These are normally taken in a pill or gummy vitamin format.

Eye cream

The skin around your eyes is thinner and more delicate than skin elsewhere on the body. As you age, this skin naturally gets thinner due to a lack of collagen which can result in wrinkles, sagging and dark circles.

While this is a completely normal and natural process, if you want to keep your skin looking brighter and more youthful, you can consider using an eye cream. Many eye creams are specially formulated to boost collagen production and tighten the area around your eyes.

Generally, eye cream should be applied on freshly washed skin and before any moisturiser or make-up to ensure the best results. They can be applied either in the morning, before bedtime or both, however, they may contain different formulas.

For daytime eye creams - look for a light cream that you can wear under your make-up, particularly with SPF in it to combat wrinkle formation. Nighttime eye creams should contain rich and hydrating ingredients to soak into your skin overnight.

Eyebrow tints

Tinting your eyebrows, especially if you have dark eyebrows already, may not seem like it’ll do much but you’ll be surprised at the difference it can make in giving you a gorgeous and full set of eyebrows. The eyebrow tint can dye tiny hairs that would normally go unnoticed to give you a healthy and well-groomed look.

While you can get this simple procedure done in a salon, you can also pick up an eyebrow tint cream and do it yourself. It involves applying the tint to your eyebrows for anywhere from a few minutes to a few hours and wiping it off or peeling it off for results lasting between a few days to 4 weeks. The dye will slowly and subtly fade over time.

It’s a painless and cheaper alternative to microblading whilst still giving you bold and full look.

To make your tint last as long as possible, keep your brows completely dry for 12 hours after your appointment (including washing your face). During the entirety of your tint, it’s best to avoid wearing oil-based makeup, face serums and face oils which can make your dye fade faster.

Eyebrow gel

Eyebrow gel (or eyebrow wax) is perfect for locking your hairs in place and securing your volumised look. They can also add volume and shine to otherwise sparse and dull eyebrows. This is one of the quickest and easiest ways of maintaining your eyebrows.

Brow gels come in all colours to suit your make up needs whether you have light or dark hair. A tinted brow gel is a great option for those looking to create natural definition, darken their eyebrows or cover up greys. For extra definition, you can use several shades.

Brow gels generally come with a spoolie (basically, a small mascara wand) for easy effortless application. Simply use the spoolie to brush your brow hairs upwards and outwards. Work the brush from root to tip to coat each part of your eyebrows evenly. Use short strokes and apply multiple layers to sparse areas.

Most everyday eyebrow gels will last the whole day and can easily be removed with your usual makeup remover and cleanser.

Skincare tips for your eyes

In addition to choosing the right products for your eyes with high-quality ingredients and correctly applying them, you can follow these simple tips for the best eye skincare regimen:

  • You can gently massage the skin around your eyes to improve circulation and reduce puffiness.
  • Avoid going to sleep whilst wearing eye makeup since that can irritate the skin and make it more brittle. Use a gentle makeup remover that’s safe to use around the eyes and never scrub or force your eye makeup off.
  • Wear sunglasses that block ultraviolet A and B (UVA and UVB) light to reduce the risk of eye wrinkles and skin cancer.
  • To further protect your eyes and eyelids, wear a hat. The brim should be at least 3 inches wide to adequately protect your eyes from the sun.
  • Be mindful when choosing products to use around your eyes. Use skincare and makeup formulas that are specifically made for the skin around your eyes and never apply products meant for other parts of the body to your eyes as they may be too harsh for the delicate skin.

It’s always a good idea to read reviews on a product before purchasing, you can get the inside scoop on the best cosmetic products for eyes by reading reviews on our site to help inform your purchasing decisions.